Trump Makes Third Supreme Court Push on Mail Ballot Limits

The administration returned to the Supreme Court Sunday for a third time, asking to enforce new Postal Service mail ballot restrictions before the midterms.

@sharedot

Trump Makes Third Supreme Court Push on Mail Ballot Limits

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Politics
  • Supreme Court
  • Mail Voting
  • 2026 Midterms

The administration returned to the Supreme Court Sunday for a third time, asking to enforce new Postal Service mail ballot restrictions before the midterms.

What happened

The Trump administration filed an emergency application to the Supreme Court on Sunday, September 6, asking the justices to put on hold a preliminary injunction issued by U.S. District Judge Indira Talwani that bars the government from enforcing key parts of a new U.S. Postal Service rule on mail ballots.

According to SCOTUSblog, the filing is the third time in less than six weeks — and the second time since Thursday — that the administration has asked the high court to intervene in the dispute.

Solicitor General D. John Sauer withdrew the administration's earlier application and filed a new one after Talwani converted her temporary restraining order into a preliminary injunction on Friday.

Why the rush

The urgency stems from the election calendar: North Carolina has already begun mailing ballots, Alabama starts September 9, and at least five more states will mail the week of September 13, per the solicitor general's filing.

"Once those ballot envelopes enter the mailstream, there is no retrieving them," Sauer wrote, arguing that each day the injunction remains makes compliance steps voluntary rather than mandatory and risks confusion.

The administration says the rule imposes only modest envelope-design and addressee-information requirements that fall within the Postal Service's congressionally conferred rulemaking authority.

What the rule requires

According to Democracy Docket, the new USPS rule, written to comply with President Trump's March executive order, requires states to make design changes to mail ballot envelopes, such as new logos and barcodes, and to submit personal information about voters who requested mail ballots to a federal online portal.

States that fail either requirement would not receive mail ballots from the Postal Service.

SCOTUSblog reports the March executive order also directed the Department of Homeland Security to compile lists of adult U.S. citizens in each state and directed the attorney general to prioritize prosecution of officials who issue federal ballots to ineligible voters.

The opposition's case

A group of 23 states led by California and the District of Columbia challenged the order in federal court in Boston, arguing it conflicts with constitutional provisions giving states power over voter eligibility and the times, places and manner of congressional elections, as SCOTUSblog recounts.

The ACLU's Voting Rights Project director Sophia Lin Lakin said there is "not a shred of evidence" states could comply within 60 days of the November election without disenfranchising voters who rely on mail ballots.

The League of Women Voters of Massachusetts argues the changes would create chaos so close to Election Day.

What's at stake

Nearly one-third of U.S. voters cast mail ballots, and control of Congress is on the line in November, so the court's response could shape how millions vote.

Democracy Docket notes the administration could not answer basic questions at Thursday's hearing about whether the USPS portal was complete or when it would come online, and reports that a whistleblower said the rushed portal effort could disenfranchise millions.

The court has previously allowed the plan to move forward without ruling on its legality, in a 10-page unsigned opinion saying the states' challenge was premature because the order had not yet been carried out.

What comes next

Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, who handles emergency appeals from Massachusetts, directed the challengers to file their response by 4 p.m. EDT on Wednesday, September 9, per SCOTUSblog.

The Justice Department argues the injunction causes irreparable harm because ballots mailed before a stay issues would permanently escape the rule, and that even after a stay, training delays would briefly postpone implementation.

Meanwhile, Missouri's separate redistricting fight is also headed to the Supreme Court, with Attorney General Catherine Hanaway seeking to overturn a 7-0 state ruling that requires the 2022 congressional maps in November, Spectrum News reports.

Sources

  1. scotusblog.com › Trump administration again appeals mail-in ballot dispute to the Supreme Court
  2. pbs.org › Trump administration makes another appeal to Supreme Court to allow mail ballot restrictions
  3. democracydocket.com › Justice Department asks Supreme Court to lift block on USPS mail voting restrictions
  4. spectrumlocalnews.com › Missouri AG takes 2025 redistricting suit to US Supreme Court

More on Politics