White House Warns Democrats Their Trump Probes May Be 'Criminality'
By @sharedot · · 7 pages
- Politics
- Congress
- Trump Administration
- Oversight
White House counsel Will Scharf warned Rep. Robert Garcia that congressional probes of the Trump administration could become 'blatant criminality.
What happened: a warning letter to the incoming Oversight chair
According to CBS News, Scharf reminded Garcia that congressional investigations must serve a "legitimate legislative purpose," and wrote that "issuing unlawful subpoenas with the intention of depriving citizens of their constitutional rights and privileges may warrant further investigation."
Garcia fired back that "Congress' authority comes from Article I of the Constitution, not from the permission of the White House."
Why it's a striking escalation
The New York Times reports that in his first term Trump resisted and stonewalled congressional investigations, hoping to stall inquiries until Democrats ran out of time — but ahead of Democrats' return to congressional control, he has adopted a more aggressive maneuver: threatening to treat some legislative oversight itself as a potential crime.
The pushback is expected to be led in part by chief of staff Stephen Miller, with the Justice Department and White House Counsel's Office laying groundwork for an all-out effort to block Democratic oversight over the next two years.
Legal experts doubt criminal charges would stick
Legal experts across the spectrum told Fox News that the administration can challenge individual subpoenas in court but faces high obstacles to criminal prosecution.
Fox News reports that Manhattan Institute's Ilya Shapiro said criminal prosecutions are "a very different animal that face a higher bar," while the Cato Institute's Molly Nixon said she doesn't think the letter is "on solid ground" in suggesting criminality.
The Constitution's Speech or Debate Clause immunizes lawmakers for legislative acts, and CBS News notes Attorney General Todd Blanche said the Justice Department has no open criminal investigations into members of Congress.
The stakes: subpoena power returns to Democrats
Following the midterms, Democrats are poised to hold at least 254 House seats and 55 Senate seats, giving them committee control and subpoena power, per CBS News.
Garcia's agenda could probe the Trump family's business dealings, a $2 billion Saudi investment in Jared Kushner's private equity fund, Trump family crypto ventures, DHS contracts, corporate donations to the new White House ballroom, and the Jeffrey Epstein scandal.
Trump on Truth Social accused Democrats of "extortion," writing "These SLEAZEBAGS should go to jail for what they are doing" and directing the Justice Department to look into the oversight push.
What comes next: courts, not criminals
Experts expect the fight to play out through lawsuits over subpoena enforcement rather than indictments.
Nixon told CBS News that even if a court finds a subpoena lacks a valid legislative purpose, "that might just mean the subpoena doesn't get enforced or that it's quashed — the criminality question is not coterminous with the legislative purpose question."
Trump's first administration litigated Democratic subpoenas to the Supreme Court, which in 2020 reiterated that subpoenas must serve a legitimate legislative purpose. Fox News reports CAP's Devon Ombres expects the White House and DOJ to "throw everything, including the kitchen sink, at subpoenas."
Garcia's own message to the administration: "Lawyer up."
Sources
- cbsnews.com › Top White House lawyer warns of "blatant criminality" in Democrats' investigations push
- nytimes.com › As Congress Plans Investigations, White House Prepares Ferocious Response
- foxnews.com › White House lawyer's hardball warning to Dems has legal experts on both sides questioning one key threat