Jack Smith Defends Trump Cases Before Hostile Senate
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Politics
- Jack Smith
- Congress
- 2026 Midterms
Jack Smith told the Senate Judiciary Committee he stands by his Trump prosecutions despite insults and a botched perjury claim.
What happened at the hearing
Former special counsel Jack Smith testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee on Tuesday, forcefully defending his two federal cases against President Donald Trump — the Jan. 6 election-interference prosecution and the classified documents case — both abandoned after Trump's 2024 win.
Smith said the investigations developed proof beyond a reasonable doubt that Trump committed serious crimes, and declared he would not be silenced "by continued threats of prosecution" from the president or others.
Republicans, including chairman Chuck Grassley, cast the probes as politically motivated overreach, while Democrats rallied to Smith's defense.
Why the session turned surprising
The hearing's most memorable moment was a spectacular backfire. Sen. Eric Schmitt of Missouri accused Smith of perjury for denying he attended an Atlanta Hawks game in February 2024, attempting to link him to Fulton County DA Fani Willis.
Smith clarified he had actually attended an Iowa Hawkeyes women's basketball game — Caitlin Clark's team — at the University of Maryland, a team-name mix-up that Sen. Amy Klobuchar chided Schmitt for.
Republican John Kennedy, meanwhile, told Smith he made him "want to throw up in my mouth," and Schmitt called Smith a "dirtbag" and a "villain."
The evidence under dispute
Much of the questioning centered on subpoenas Smith's team issued for toll records of Republican lawmakers contacted by Trump or his aides around Jan. 6, 2021.
Smith said the subpoenas were standard practice, approved by the Justice Department's Public Integrity Section, and provided corroborating evidence that Trump and alleged co-conspirators tried to exploit the Capitol violence to delay certification of Biden's win.
Toll records show call timing and duration but not content, and Democrats noted the first Trump administration's Justice Department also sought such records. Rep. Jim Jordan has nonetheless referred Smith to the DOJ for possible perjury over his prior testimony about the records.
The stakes for the rule of law
Smith warned of what he called an unprecedented assault on the rule of law, pointing to the terminations of prosecutors on his team, which he said deprived the government of crucial expertise.
NBC News reports the Trump administration has launched a "grand conspiracy" investigation into federal law enforcement actions dating back to 2016, and defense attorneys told a court last week that the DOJ appears interested in probing the circumstances of the 2022 FBI search of Mar-a-Lago.
Sen. Cory Booker said prosecutors were fired for doing their jobs, then vilified and harassed.
Political context heading into midterms
The hearing lands weeks before the November midterms, which will decide whether Republicans keep the House and Senate.
President Trump told reporters he plans a 32-day campaign tour through states including Texas and Ohio, projecting confidence even as many polls show Democrats leading in key House races and challenging for Senate control, with voters focused on gasoline prices and the Iran conflict.
Dick Durbin called baseless conspiracy theories meant to whitewash Jan. 6.
What comes next
Smith remains under a House Republican criminal referral from Rep. Jim Jordan, though former federal prosecutors told NBC News that a perjury case against him would be a tough one to bring.
The classified documents portion of Smith's final report cannot be released under an order from Trump-appointed Judge Aileen Cannon, and the Justice Department says answering questions on it would violate that order.
Sources
- nbcnews.com › Jack Smith defends Trump probes in Senate hearing filled with GOP insults
- latimes.com › Ex-Trump prosecutor Smith forcefully defends investigations as Republicans assail his team's tactics
- telegraphherald.com › Ex-Trump prosecutor Smith forcefully defends investigations as Republicans assail his team's tactics
- atlantanewsfirst.com › Hawks? Hawkeyes? Missouri senator appears to mistake teams while questioning ex-Trump prosecutor
- wsfa.com › Ex-prosecutor Smith defends Trump probes amid GOP attacks
- sentinelcolorado.com › Ex-Trump prosecutor Smith forcefully defends investigations as Republicans assail his team's tactics
- jpost.com › Donald Trump announces 32-day campaign tour ahead of US midterm elections