Supreme Court Faces Third Ruling on Missouri's Map

The Supreme Court must decide for a third time whether Missouri's November elections use the 2022 map or the contested 2025 gerrymander.

@sharedot

Supreme Court Faces Third Ruling on Missouri's Map

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Politics
  • Supreme Court
  • Redistricting
  • Missouri
  • Elections 2026

The Supreme Court must decide for a third time whether Missouri's November elections use the 2022 map or the contested 2025 gerrymander.

What Happened

On Tuesday night, challengers to Missouri's new congressional map asked the Supreme Court to block a decision by a federal appeals court in St. Louis that instructed the state to use the 2025 map in the November elections.

SCOTUSblog reports that lawyer Abha Khanna told the justices its orders 'are not invitations for a lower court to repackage the same relief and try again.' Justice Brett Kavanaugh directed the state and map supporters to respond by 2 p.m.

EDT on Wednesday. Four amicus briefs were filed Wednesday, three supporting the map opponents, People Not Politicians.

Why It's Surprising

The dispute has now reached the justices twice from two separate court systems, and each intervention flips the map mid-election.

The Missouri Supreme Court ruled unanimously on Sept. 3 that the referendum petition against the map was 'legal, sufficient, and timely,' meaning the 2025 map never took effect.

Days later, Chief U.S. District Judge Stephen Clark issued a temporary restraining order requiring the state to use it, and after the Supreme Court stayed his order on Sept. 10, the 8th Circuit on Monday reinstated the same relief anyway.

The Evidence on the Ballot Ground

According to SCOTUSblog, the 8th Circuit's unsigned 35-page opinion held that 'only use of the 2025 map complies with the Constitution and federal law,' because using the 2022 map in November after the August primary ran under the 2025 map violates Article I, Section 2.

The challengers counter that the ruling 'identifies from whole cloth a right under Article I, Section II that no federal court has recognized.' KMBC reports the Campaign Legal Center and ACLU groups argue the 8th Circuit 'has in essence ordered the district court to disobey this Court's stay order.'

Voting Has Already Started

Democracy Docket reports that local election officials have sent overseas and absentee ballots using the 2022 lines, and that absentee voting by mail and in person had already begun by the time of the latest filing.

SCOTUSblog notes that Sept. 22 was the deadline to print absentee ballots and that People Not Politicians' director Richard von Glahn had already cast his ballot under the 2022 map on Tuesday.

The group warns that at best already-cast votes would be thrown out, and at worst voters would be precluded from voting at all.

The Stakes

The 2025 map was adopted with President Donald Trump's encouragement and is intended to give Republicans an additional House seat in the November 2026 elections.

According to Democracy Docket, Republican candidates wrote that more than 1.4 million Missourians could not vote for the nominees who will appear on their November ballot under the 2022 map.

Florida, Texas and 20 other states filed a brief supporting the 2025 map, arguing the state-wide map switch creates confusion for voters, candidates and election officials, per KMBC.

What Comes Next

The Supreme Court has not yet ruled on People Not Politicians' request, which asks the justices either to clarify that their Sept. 10 order still controls or to pause the 8th Circuit's ruling. SCOTUSblog reports the 8th Circuit put its mandate on hold until 5 p.m.

CDT on Sept. 28 to give the justices time to weigh in.

State officials told the Court that a stay would be the fifth time a court ordered Missouri to use a different map since Sept. 3, and warned that county election officials have already started printing ballots in compliance with Judge Clark's order.

Sources

  1. scotusblog.com › Missouri congressional redistricting battle goes to Supreme Court for the third time
  2. kmbc.com › Amicus briefs filed as Missouri congressional map fight awaits Supreme Court decision
  3. democracydocket.com › Missouri Republicans make final plea to Supreme Court to revive gerrymandered map

More on Politics