Water Bottle DNA Cracks 1985 Hellewell Murder After 41 Years
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- True Crime
- Cold Case
- Dna Genealogy
DNA from a discarded water bottle led to a first-degree murder charge against a Smithfield man in Hillary Hellewell's 1985 killing.
A 41-Year-Old Case Gets Its Arrest
On Tuesday, Oct. 6, 2026, William Morton, 61, of Smithfield, Rhode Island, was arrested and charged with first-degree murder in the 1985 killing of Hillary Hellewell, a 22-year-old Jamestown woman found dead on a Newport sidewalk.
Hellewell was found unresponsive on Anthony Street on the morning of May 19, 1985, and the medical examiner determined she had been sexually assaulted and strangled, ruling her death a homicide.
Rhode Island Attorney General Peter Neronha, who knew Hellewell personally, announced the case at a news conference flanked by Newport Police Chief Ryan Duffy and the cold case unit, telling reporters, "She was just an amazing, fun, energetic person."
Why the Breakthrough Is Remarkable
The arrest is striking because Rhode Island had no DNA testing capability in 1985, when the crime occurred — the state only achieved DNA testing in 2004, according to the Providence Journal via Newport Daily News.
Evidence preserved from Hellewell's white pants for more than four decades finally yielded a DNA profile, and that profile did not match anyone investigators initially considered.
According to WJAR, analysts compared the profile against samples from men who attended the gathering Hellewell left that night, men close to her, and the intoxicated man she left with — and every one of them was excluded.
The case had quietly stayed with Newport investigators, one of whom, retired investigator James Evan Hazel, reportedly carried the DNA sequence in his wallet for years.
From Family Tree to a Woonsocket Concert
Decades later, genetic genealogy work pointed investigators toward a specific family line, identifying two half-brothers of William Morton through a paternal relative, according to Newport Daily News.
The cold case was reopened in 2023, and once Morton emerged as a suspect, investigators surveilled him. According to WJAR, in August investigators followed Morton and collected a discarded water bottle.
Cold case investigator Michael Naylor, per Providence Journal reporting carried by Newport Daily News, tracked Morton to a concert at the Stadium Theatre in Woonsocket on Aug. 21, watched him buy two bottles of water and popcorn, and seized the bottle he left on an empty seat.
Prosecutors learned on Sept. 24 that Morton's 2026 DNA profile was consistent with the 1985 profile from the victim's pants and a blue T-shirt found near her body.
A Prior Conviction and Grand-Jury Risk
The charged suspect was not new to Rhode Island's courts. According to WJAR, in a separate 1985 Newport case, Morton was convicted of sexually assaulting a 15-year-old, and his appeal was denied in 1989, according to Rhode Island Supreme Court records.
Neronha said a grand jury could review additional charges as the case proceeds. The disclosure gives the case a second historical layer: the same year Hellewell was killed, the man now charged in her death had already been convicted of a sexual assault in Newport.
Investigators emphasized the case was built on the preserved physical evidence, not any confession.
The Stakes for Hellewell's Family
Neronha used the announcement to address what the breakthrough means for victims' families, saying that "closure" is not a tangible thing and that victims of violent crime and their families often never fully heal, especially when they have more questions than answers.
According to WJAR, he noted that by harnessing the latest advancements in DNA technology, Rhode Island has now found answers in four previously unsolved cases over the past year, with more on the horizon.
Chief Duffy added that the passage of time does not diminish the commitment to seeking justice, and praised the Newport Police Department's Criminal Investigation Division and the Attorney General's Cold Case Unit.
What Comes Next in Court
Morton was arraigned in District Court in Newport before Judge J. Terence Houlihan and ordered held without bail on Tuesday, according to Providence Journal reporting carried by Newport Daily News. WJAR reports a status conference is scheduled for Oct. 20.
For devoted true-crime followers, the case is a textbook example of why preserved evidence matters: a 1985 crime scene item, a 2004 lab capability, a 2023 reopening, genealogy in the 2020s, and finally a 2026 surveilled water bottle converged on one suspect four decades later.
As the case moves toward the Oct. 20 conference, prosecutors have signaled the charges could still expand through a grand jury review.