Murdaugh's Lawyers Claim SLED Investigator Lied to Jury

Alex Murdaugh's lawyers claimed at a Nov. 13 hearing the lead investigator lied to the grand jury and asked a judge to dismiss the murder indictment.

@sharedot

Murdaugh's Lawyers Claim SLED Investigator Lied to Jury

By @sharedot · · 6 pages

  • True Crime
  • Alex Murdaugh
  • Murdaugh Retrial
  • South Carolina

Alex Murdaugh's lawyers claimed at a Nov. 13 hearing the lead investigator lied to the grand jury and asked a judge to dismiss the murder indictment.

What Happened at the November 13 Hearing

Alex Murdaugh's attorneys appeared before Circuit Judge Debra McCaslin on Friday, November 13, asking the court to dismiss the murder indictment against him without prejudice.

According to Us Weekly, the defense claims former lead State Law Enforcement Division investigator David Owen lied while testifying before the Colleton County grand jury in 2022.

McCaslin did not rule during the hearing, but per Us Weekly she said she would try to finish a written order on the dismissal request by Friday, November 20. Attorney Jim Griffin described the request as a reboot: 'Go back to square one and present the case anew to the Colleton County grand jury.'

Why the Overturn Was Already a Shock

The hearing lands months after a staggering reversal. On May 13, 2026, the South Carolina Supreme Court unanimously overturned Murdaugh's 2023 murder convictions for the killings of his wife Maggie, 52, and son Paul, 22, ordering a new trial.

The five-member court cited the 'breathtaking and disgraceful effort' of former Colleton County Clerk of Court Becky Hill to 'undermine the jury process,' finding her conduct triggered a presumption of prejudice the State could not rebut.

Chief Justice John Kittredge called Hill a 'rogue clerk of court' during February oral arguments, according to ABC News.

The T-Shirt and Ammunition Claims

Us Weekly reports the defense is focusing on the white T-shirt Murdaugh wore when he said he found Maggie and Paul. Attorneys claim Owen failed to tell the grand jury that an initial report found 'no blood' on the shirt, even though SLED's lab reportedly said so.

Expert Tom Bevel initially said stains were consistent with blood transfers, not bullet spatter, then later cited over 100 spatter stains after examining photographs altered in Photoshop.

Griffin also argued Owen misled the grand jury about ammunition found on the property; lead prosecutor Creighton Waters countered it 'was not overtly false,' saying it reflected what the agent understood at the time.

The Stakes and What Comes Next

The stakes are high on both sides. Attorney General Alan Wilson said after the May ruling that his office will 'aggressively' seek to retry Murdaugh, possibly by the end of 2026, stressing the decision 'does not mean Murdaugh will be released.'

Murdaugh remains imprisoned, serving a 27-year state sentence and 40-year federal sentence for financial crimes.

The state supreme court also set guardrails for a retrial, saying if financial crimes evidence is admitted again, prosecutors must present it efficiently rather than over 12.5 hours as in the first trial.

Murdaugh's lawyers said they 'look forward to a new trial conducted consistent with the Constitution' and maintain he did not kill his wife and son.

Sources

  1. usmagazine.com › Alex Murdaugh’s Lawyers Claim Investigator Lied About Evidence in Wife and Son’s Murders
  2. abcnews.com › Alex Murdaugh murder convictions overturned by South Carolina Supreme Court

More on True Crime