Federal Judge Reinstates Missouri GOP Map Hours After SCOTUS Denial

Minutes after Justice Kavanaugh rejected Missouri's emergency bid, a federal judge ordered the state to use its Republican-drawn congressional map in November anyway.

@sharedot

Federal Judge Reinstates Missouri GOP Map Hours After SCOTUS Denial

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Politics
  • Missouri Redistricting
  • Supreme Court
  • Elections

Minutes after Justice Kavanaugh rejected Missouri's emergency bid, a federal judge ordered the state to use its Republican-drawn congressional map in November anyway.

What happened: two courts, two opposite answers

Missouri's congressional map was thrown into turmoil on Tuesday by two conflicting federal rulings. First, Justice Brett Kavanaugh denied Secretary of State Denny Hoskins' emergency application to stay the Missouri Supreme Court's ruling that the GOP-drawn 2025 map never legally took effect.

Minutes later, U.S. District Judge Stephen Clark issued a temporary restraining order in a separate lawsuit barring state officials from using "any congressional district map other than the HB 1 map" for the November 3 election.

Clark, a Trump appointee, required Missouri to conduct the midterms under the new Republican-favoring map it used in the August primaries.

Why it is surprising: Kavanaugh refused, a lower court complied

The reversal is striking because the relief Hoskins could not obtain from the Supreme Court arrived from a lower federal judge almost immediately afterward.

Kavanaugh did not refer the emergency appeal to the full court, signaling he did not consider it significant enough, and offered no reasoning, according to CNN.

Yet in a parallel suit filed Friday by Republican candidates led by Rep. Bob Onder, Clark granted the same outcome on different grounds — notably rejecting the plaintiffs' Elections Clause theory and instead resting the order on Article I, Section 2 and Equal Protection claims about switching maps between the primary and general election.

The evidence: primaries held under the disputed map

Clark found the plaintiffs have a "high probability of success" on the argument that changing districts after the August 4 primary could effectively nullify some voters' primary ballots by moving them into districts whose nominees they had no chance to select, per Democracy Docket.

He also endorsed what he called a "Purcell in reverse" logic, concluding that preserving the map used in the primary disturbs election rules less than swapping maps weeks before the general election.

"Widespread voter confusion would inevitably follow," Clark wrote, according to CNN and St. Louis Public Radio.

The stakes: a House seat and a statewide standoff

The 2025 map targets Democratic Rep. Emanuel Cleaver's Kansas City-based 5th District, stretching it into rural Republican areas; CNN reports that blocking it for this year would net Republicans nine seats from redistricting efforts in other states, in a fight over the narrowly held House.

Meanwhile, the standoff is direct: the state's highest court has held the 2022 map is the only map legally in force, while a federal judge is prohibiting officials from using it.

STLPR reports that Missouri Supreme Court Chief Justice Brent Powell ordered Hoskins to appear Thursday and show cause why he should not be held in contempt for instructing election officials to use the 2025 map.

Election officials caught in between

Local election administrators describe impossible instructions. Boone County Clerk Brianna Lennon told St. Louis Public Radio that officials face "diametrically opposed" orders — the state supreme court requiring the 2022 map and the federal court forbidding it.

St. State officials, including Gov. Mike Kehoe, said the HB 1 map will be used because Tuesday was the ballot deadline.

What comes next: the 8th Circuit and a stay request

Attorneys for People Not Politicians Missouri immediately appealed Clark's order to the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals and said they would seek a stay there and from Justice Kavanaugh, according to STLPR.

Attorney Chuck Hatfield argued a federal district judge cannot overrule the Missouri Supreme Court and filed an emergency contempt motion against Hoskins.

Sources

  1. democracydocket.com › Federal judge revives Missouri GOP gerrymander right after Supreme Court rejects state's emergency bid
  2. cnn.com › Federal judge orders Missouri to proceed with GOP-friendly map after Supreme Court balked
  3. nbcnews.com › Conflicting court rulings leave Missouri's congressional map in limbo
  4. stlpr.org › Missouri's redistricting fight in turmoil as U.S. Supreme Court and federal orders clash

More on Politics