DOJ Tells Court Trump Can Keep Banning CNN, MS NOW, Politico
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Politics
- Press Freedom
- First Amendment
- White House
- Trump Administration
The Justice Department argued Friday that President Trump can lawfully bar CNN, MS NOW and Politico from the White House ahead of Thursday's hearing.
What happened
In a late-Friday court filing, the Justice Department argued that President Donald Trump should be allowed to reinstate his ban of CNN, MS NOW and Politico from White House grounds, ahead of a Thursday hearing on the outlets' request for a preliminary injunction.
The administration claimed the outlets published stories that adversely affect national security and failed to meet a "minimum requirements of professionalism" standard, arguing that restricting access removes an avenue for obtaining harmful information.
A temporary restraining order from U.S. District Judge Timothy Kelly, issued September 24, currently forces the White House to keep the reporters' hard passes active, but it expires next week.
Why it is surprising
The filing doubles down even though Kelly, a Trump appointee, already found the administration violated due process by revoking credentials without notice or a way to object.
According to MS NOW, Kelly wrote the record was "bereft" of any formally articulated standards, calling the White House's September 22 letters, sent four days after the ban began, "so vague it hardly does the trick." According to Deadline, Kelly said he is bound by the 1977 precedent Sherrill v.
Knight, which bars arbitrary denial of press access, and DOJ argued Sherrill still permits the ban because the White House has a "compelling interest."
The evidence and the gaps
According to CNN, the filing offered no new evidence that the outlets actually published classified information; the department argued it was not required to show that, and instead leaned on the idea that spreading "misinformation" is itself a national security risk.
Kelly earlier noted that the cited stories did not all relate to national security, since the letters mentioned reporting that threatened security "and/or" spread falsehoods.
The outlets, represented by Theodore Boutrous, called the ban an "unlawful assault on the most fundamental First Amendment freedoms" and said it was retaliation meant to coerce favorable coverage.
Retaliation continues on the ground
Even with credentials restored, the administration has kept restricting the targeted outlets.
According to CNN, the White House did not allow CNN to travel with the president on Air Force One to Tennessee as scheduled under the TV pool rotation, and MS NOW reports the White House has continued blocking CNN from its duties as part of the five-network television pool.
MS NOW also reported it took nearly 12 hours to reinstate the journalists' credentials after Kelly's ruling. The Committee to Protect Journalists says it joined an amicus brief with 78 organizations supporting the outlets, calling the ban part of a broader pattern of press intimidation.
The stakes for press access
The outlets argue the ban violates both the First Amendment and the due process clause of the Fifth Amendment, and warn in their filings that the White House will "immediately reinstate a complete ban" if the order lapses.
Circuit precedent, as reported by MS NOW, holds that press access to the White House may not be revoked without due process.
The First Amendment question remains unsettled: Kelly ruled only on due process grounds last week, and a similar 2018 case over Jim Acosta's credentials ended before those claims were resolved.
A ruling for the administration would let a president exclude specific news organizations from covering the presidency.
What comes next
Judge Kelly will hear arguments on the preliminary injunction Thursday, the same day his current order expires, and he has indicated he intends to "rule expeditiously," according to MS NOW.
If granted, longer-term relief would keep CNN, MS NOW and Politico on the grounds while the full case plays out; if not, the administration has signaled it will revive the ban.
The White House, for its part, maintains the ban is lawful and not viewpoint discrimination, while the outlets' legal team says the president's press ban is "indefensible" and the harm to the First Amendment and the public is profound.
Sources
- cnn.com › Justice Department asks court to let Trump reinstate White House press ban | CNN Politics
- deadline.com › DOJ Argues CNN & Other Outlets Can Be Banned From White House
- ms.now › Trump administration insists in new court filing it can ban MS NOW, CNN and Politico from White House
- cpj.org › CPJ joins legal effort to restore White House press access