Jeremiah Smith's 4-TD Night Makes Him the Heisman Favorite
By @sharedot · · 7 pages
- Theater
- College Football
- Heisman Trophy
- Jeremiah Smith
Ohio State's Jeremiah Smith ran up 217 yards and four touchdowns against Illinois, and oddsmakers now list him as the Heisman Trophy front-runner.
What Happened: A Record Night in Columbus
Ohio State beat Illinois 42-19 on Saturday, Sept. 26, 2026, and wide receiver Jeremiah Smith turned the game into a personal showcase. He finished with 12 receptions for 217 yards and four touchdown catches, three of which came in the first half, with the fourth arriving early in the fourth quarter.
According to Sporting News (via Yahoo Sports), Smith became the first and only Buckeye receiver ever to post more than 10 catches, more than 200 yards, and four scores in a single game.
Fox News' OutKick adds that he became only the fifth Ohio State player with four touchdowns in one game, tying the school's single-game record.
Why It Is Surprising: A Receiver atop the Heisman Race
The surprising part is positional. FOX Sports notes that no pass-catcher has won the Heisman Trophy since DeVonta Smith, yet after Saturday the sportsbook moved Jeremiah Smith to +320 favorite, up from +1000 and third place.
That leapfrogged quarterbacks Trinidad Chambliss of Ole Miss and Darian Miami quarterback Darian Mensah of Miami.
On the DraftKings board cited by Sporting News, Chambliss sits at +440 and Mensah at +450, while FanDuel lists Chambliss at +430 and Mensah at +440 — a receiver holding the top line over a crowded quarterback field is the story theatergoers of the sport are buzzing about.
The Evidence: Highlight Plays and Career Highs
FOX Sports details how Smith got there: he torched Illinois defensive back Mac Resetich on a 72-yard touchdown and won two jump balls on fade routes in the red zone. His 217 yards broke his previous career high of 187, set as a true freshman in the Rose Bowl win over Oregon.
He also secured his first-career three-touchdown game before halftime with 150 first-half receiving yards. Buckeyes coach Ryan Day told reporters, per Sporting News, "If there's a better player in the country, it's hard to imagine. I think he's taken his game to the next level this year."
The Stakes: Season Numbers and the Chase
The season totals are staggering by any measure.
Sporting News charts Smith at 33 catches, 617 yards, and seven touchdowns through four games in 2026, following 1,315 yards as a freshman in 2024 and 1,243 in 2025; FOX Sports pegs his yardage at 605 on the season, so outlets differ slightly on the exact figure.
OutKick frames the wider context: Ohio State has now outscored opponents 101-22 in two games since its upset loss to Texas, and it has produced a first-round wide receiver in five consecutive drafts from 2022 through 2026.
What Comes Next: Iowa and a November Race
The Heisman race, as Sporting News reminds readers, will run through November, and Smith has merely separated himself early.
The schedule offers an immediate stress test: Ohio State visits the defensively-stout Iowa Hawkeyes on Saturday, Oct. 3, a game OutKick calls the Buckeyes' biggest test since the Texas loss.
Behind Smith, FOX Sports lists Chambliss, Mensah, Kamario Taylor at +850, CJ Carr at +1400, and Malachi Toney at +1600, with Julian Sayin and Arch Manning tied at +2500.
If Smith keeps producing at this rate, he would be the first receiver since DeVonta Smith to take the trophy to New York in December.