White House Warns Democrats Probes May Be 'Criminality'
By @sharedot · · 7 pages
- Politics
- Congress
- Trump Administration
- Congressional Oversight
White House counsel Will Scharf warned Rep. Robert Garcia that aggressive investigations of Trump officials may cross into 'blatant criminality.'
What happened: a warning letter to the incoming Oversight chair
White House counsel Will Scharf issued a letter dated Monday to Rep. Robert Garcia, the top Democrat on the House Oversight Committee who would likely chair the panel in the new Democratic-controlled Congress seated in January.
Scharf wrote that threats to executive branch officials designed to deter them from public service, or process designed merely to abuse or instill fear, "may cross the line into blatant criminality."
Garcia, who told Trump officials to "lawyer up" after last week's midterm victories, responded that "it appears Donald Trump has something to hide" and that Congress's investigative powers do not need the "permission of the White House."
The letter's existence was first reported by Punchbowl News, according to the AP report carried by The Killeen Daily Herald.
Why it is surprising: criminality claims against standard oversight
The warning stands out because congressional investigations are a standard oversight function of Congress, yet the White House is suggesting they could amount to a crime.
According to PBS NewsHour, New York Times federal law enforcement reporter Devlin Barrett said the letter carries little weight as a legal document but matters as a political one, signaling the administration intends to "fight every subpoena you send us."
Attorney General Todd Blanche told CNN there "could be" a crime to investigate if Democratic rhetoric turned threatening, though he later struck a more conciliatory tone in Missouri, saying Congress has always had oversight authority and the Justice Department would keep working with it.
Barrett noted the administration has already probed Democratic lawmakers on shaky premises, such as a video urging military officers not to follow illegal orders.
The evidence: subpoenas, resignations and a 'wartime footing'
The confrontation unfolds alongside a wave of high-profile Justice Department resignations following the Democratic wins.
PBS NewsHour reports the departures include Harmeet Dhillon of the Civil Rights Division, Jason Quinones, who oversaw investigations of the president's opponents, Brett Shumate, and John Eisenberg, with reporting showing White House displeasure at officials who did not meet expectations, including the outgoing U.S. attorney in Miami whose grand conspiracy investigation produced fewer charges than hoped.
DOJ also warned field office leaders to prepare for a "wartime footing" when Democrats take over or leave, PBS reports.
Meanwhile, Aaron Reitz, the U.S. attorney for the Southern District of Texas, wrote to Sen. Richard Blumenthal telling him to preserve records relevant to his investigations, calling his efforts an intent to deprive citizens of constitutional rights, according to the AP report.
The stakes: balance of power and confirmed vacancies
The showdown carries major implications for congressional authority and the balance between the branches of government.
Garcia is preparing a vast oversight agenda covering how Trump and his family became wealthier since returning to office, the administration's handling of the Jeffrey Epstein investigation, ICE operations, the White House ballroom, mineral deals, and Trump's crypto dealings with envoy Steve Witkoff.
Because permanent replacements for departing DOJ officials require Senate confirmation, PBS reports it may be extremely hard to confirm replacements, potentially locking current officials in place for the rest of the administration.
Senate-confirmed vacancies could also leave the department headed by acting officials when subpoenas start arriving.
What comes next: subpoenas, impeachment talk and state fights
Blumenthal said he "will not be intimidated" and accused the administration of weaponizing the Justice Department against Congress. Incoming House Ethics chair Rep. Mark DeSaulnier, D-Calif., said the warnings would not stop him: "I don't work for a mafia, a mob organization."
Some Republicans urged restraint, with outgoing Rep. Thomas Massie hoping Democrats hold "real hearings about real things, not another Russia-gate."
Jamie Raskin, poised to chair House Judiciary, has raised impeaching Attorney General Todd Blanche, which PBS reports reflects a department facing mass departures and poor morale.
PBS also notes that with states like Texas now run by Democratic officials, the administration is preparing for more fights with local governments over ICE cooperation.