Slate Calls SNL's 'Sister' the Show's Most Brutal Sketch
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Comedy
- Snl
- John Mulaney
- Sketch Comedy
- Sister Sketch
Slate hails John Mulaney's mock pharma ad 'Sister' as SNL's best sketch in a long time, skewering the gendered burden of elder care.
Mulaney's Seventh Turn Delivers a Mock Pharma Ad
Instead, a three-minute digital short called "Sister" staged a fake pharmaceutical ad for an eldercare solution: a live-in, 24/7 provider that is completely free, "and also your sister."
Mulaney's pitch is that he loves his aging father but didn't want a nursing home, and a private aide could cost thousands a week. The sketch was reportedly written by Mikey Day and Streeter Seidell — surprisingly, Slate notes, two men.
The Video: Every Bitter Detail, Played Straight
Watch on YouTube · Saturday Night Live · 2:58
The short lands its satire in specifics rather than abstraction. Andrew Dismukes says he doesn't want to help his aging mother in the bathroom, and "Sister doesn't either, but she will, whereas I won't."
Kenan Thompson promises the service won't touch the men's inheritance: "Since your parents' will predates their dementia, using Sister won't change your inheritance. You'll still get 50 percent of the house she's currently deep-cleaning."
Signing up is easy — simply text "dad fell" and Sister will quit her job, break her lease, and move halfway across the country. It works, the ad explains, because years of internalized sexism warped Sister's brain into thinking caretaking is her responsibility.
Why It Cut So Deep for Viewers
Slate argues the sketch's power lies in mocking an accepted gender dynamic everyone knows but rarely interrogates, and calls the result brutal and entertaining in equal measure — even while conceding, via a Slate Slack discussion, that occasionally Sister is Brother.
The writer, an eldest-daughter "Sister" herself, says she has long braced for this future, one films like American Fiction have also surfaced.
In her reading, the sketch proves that men's weaponized incompetence is being noticed by men themselves, and that audiences' incredulous laughter shows how widely the dynamic is recognized. Whether any of these brothers care enough to change it may be a different story, she writes.
Viewers Agreed It Was the Night's Truth-Teller
BuzzFeed reports the episode's reaction was fierce, with "Sister" alongside a boomer-Woodstock sketch among the night's standouts.
The Woodstock bit — which BuzzFeed says some viewers called the best in show history — imagined 1969 hippies planning to "buy all the houses," hoard money by 1985, and later scare their kids about everything they themselves enjoyed.
It drew nearly 1 million YouTube views in a day, and one X user called it "EASILY the most accurate SNL skit in years," urging everyone over 60 to watch it weekly. BuzzFeed ties the sketch's 1985 reference to peak Reagan-era America, Reaganomics and the "Just Say No" era.
What Else Made the Episode Sing
Variety praised Phoebe Bridgers' first solo musical appearance since 2021: her performance of "Still Standing," a song about her father's death, ended with her face transforming into a skull via UV-sensitive makeup hidden under her regular makeup — a practical effect, not a digital one — which Variety says emotionally elevated the song.
She paired it with the joyful "Bobby." Stereogum notes the show also skipped its traditional 10-to-one slot, cutting a sketch in which Mulaney's Pope Leo XIV meets James Austin Johnson's Bob Dylan, riffing on Dylan's real recent meeting with the Pope.
Slate adds Mulaney's nine-minute carriage-horse musical medley, "The Little Park of Horrors," with a returning Bowen Yang.
The Stakes for SNL's Season
Slate concludes that while other episodes this season may have earned higher ratings, Mulaney's seventh turn shows why he remains one of SNL's most capable captains, with a knack for delighting viewers one second and distilling a complex social truth the next.
The viral response BuzzFeed documents — near-a-million overnight views and hot takes across X — suggests the "Sister" and Woodstock sketches are the kinds of bits that outlive their airdate, echoing the cult-classic potential Stereogum says the show usually parks in its cut 10-to-one slot.
For devoted comedy watchers, the episode now reads as a benchmark for what the show's political, personal satire can still do.
Sources
- slate.com › SNL Just Aired Its Best—and Most Brutal—Sketch in a Long Time
- buzzfeed.com › This "SNL" Woodstock Sketch Is Being Hailed As The Best In Show History
- variety.com › Phoebe Bridgers' Skeletal Transformation on 'SNL' Wasn't Just a Startling Special Effect
- stereogum.com › Bob Dylan Meets The Pope In Cut-For-Time SNL Sketch