SCOTUS Lets Trump White House Ballroom Proceed
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Politics
- Supreme Court
- White House
- Trump Administration
Chief Justice Roberts issued a temporary stay allowing construction to continue while the Supreme.
Supreme Court Issues Temporary Stay
Chief Justice John Roberts issued a one-sentence administrative stay on Friday that paused a federal district court judge's injunction barring further construction on President Donald Trump's new White House ballroom, according to Time Magazine.
The stay gives the full Supreme Court more time to consider the Trump Administration's request to keep the injunction on hold while it seeks further review. Time Magazine reports that there is no established timeline for when Roberts or the Court might take further action.
The ruling came just before the aboveground portion of the $400 million project was set to be halted.
Why the Ruling Is Surprising
The stay is notable because two lower courts had ruled against the Administration.
According to Time Magazine, Senior Judge Richard Leon of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia found in March that the National Trust for Historic Preservation was likely to succeed on its claim that the project required congressional approval, and he barred aboveground construction.
Time Magazine also reports that a D.C. Circuit panel upheld the modified injunction in August, stating that each President is a 'temporary tenant, not the owner' of the White House.
Roberts's order temporarily reverses that trajectory.
The Legal Arguments at Center
The legal challenge was brought by the National Trust for Historic Preservation, which argues that a President cannot unilaterally make a major permanent change to federally owned property without congressional authorization, pointing to the Constitution's Property Clause, according to Time Magazine.
Time Magazine reports that the group reiterated that the Administration has no unilateral legal authority to build on the site of the now-demolished East Wing unless Congress expressly approves.
The Trump Administration argues the project is an integrated military and ballroom complex vital for national security, with Solicitor General John Sauer stating that every day without the complex's security features presents unacceptable risk.
Ballroom or Military Complex?
Time Magazine reports that the 90,000-square-foot project comprises a luxury ballroom meant to host 650 seated guests, with an underground military complex beneath it featuring protective missile-resistant steel columns, drone-proof roofing materials, and bullet, ballistic, and blast-proof glass.
Lower courts treated the two components separately, exempting underground security construction from the injunction, according to Time Magazine.
The Administration now argues the entire project is integrated and that halting aboveground work would compromise structural integrity and security functions. Trump has claimed a drone port will feature a launching deck and defense station.
The Stakes for Presidential Power
Time Magazine reports that Kimberly Wehle, a professor of law at the University of Baltimore School of Law, said Roberts's stay is 'giving Trump exactly what he wants' by allowing construction to advance while courts assess legality.
She called it 'the Supreme Court greenlighting unconstitutional, lawless behavior by the President' and questioned whether the President is being accommodated because the project had gone too far to undo.
Time Magazine also notes that the Administration claimed 65 percent of construction was already done as of August 13, with the framework expected to be substantially complete by November. The official completion date is set for August 2028.
What Comes Next
No court has issued a final ruling on the project's legality, according to Time Magazine. The next steps will likely include determining whether the renovation consists of two distinct projects—aboveground and below—or a singular integrated build.
Time Magazine reports that the National Trust stated the administrative stay is not a final decision on the merits and that it awaits further action.
If the project is ultimately found unlawful after construction is substantially complete, the case could present unusual questions about what remedy remains available, including whether a court could order the structure altered or removed.
The outcome could set a precedent on whether a President can act first and seek permission later.