After First Ship Catch, Starship Faces Reuse and Refueling Tests

SpaceX's first Ship catch is behind it; the real hurdles are rapid stage reuse, orbital refueling and the 2028 Artemis IV lunar landing.

@sharedot

After First Ship Catch, Starship Faces Reuse and Refueling Tests

By @sharedot · · 7 pages

  • Space
  • Spacex
  • Starship

SpaceX's first Ship catch is behind it; the real hurdles are rapid stage reuse, orbital refueling and the 2028 Artemis IV lunar landing.

The first Ship catch in history

Starship's upper stage returned from 14 orbits and settled into the Mechazilla tower's chopstick arms at Starbase on Saturday, Nov. 14, roughly 22.5 hours after lifting off on Friday, Nov. 13.

SpaceX had caught its Super Heavy booster three times before, but had never even attempted to catch a Ship, whose return from higher altitude and faster speeds is far more involved.

SpaceX spokesperson Dan Huot called the landing 'the holy grail of spaceflight' during the webcast, and NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman wrote that 'it was almost magic.'

The booster miss mars the double catch

The plan had been an unprecedented twofer: recovering both Super Heavy and Ship at the same pad. According to space.com, the Super Heavy booster was diverted to a Gulf of Mexico splashdown on Friday evening after a low-fuel alarm.

Fox Business reports the booster exploded over the Gulf of America after its engines shut down prematurely during descent, and that engineers are investigating the cause.

SpaceX has not recovered both stages in one flight yet, leaving the full-recovery profile still unproven even after the Ship milestone.

Rapid reflight is the next mountain

The catch is only part of the reuse equation. Per space.com, SpaceX has reflown Super Heavy boosters twice — Booster 14 flew on Flights 7 and 9, Booster 15 on Flights 8 and 11 — but months separated each reflight, and no Ship has ever been reused.

Before Flight 15, Elon Musk said the company wants to reuse both stages, and Flight 15's Ship itself may yet fly again.

Musk has targeted 10,000 Starship launches per year by 2030, more than one liftoff an hour, to support a planned 100,000-satellite Starlink V3 network and a Starmind AI constellation of one million spacecraft, per space.com.

Artemis IV and the refueling hurdle

NASA selected Ship as the first crewed lunar lander for the Artemis program, with a crewed landing near the lunar south pole targeted on Artemis IV in 2028.

space.com reports SpaceX must add a crew cabin and life-support system, and that a NASA presentation last month said 'Cabin 1,' a full-scale ground prototype, is on track to be finished by year's end.

Deep-space flights also require orbital refueling from tanker Ships, with outside estimates running as high as 22 tanker visits against Musk's cited range of six to eight. If Starship isn't ready, NASA may fall back on Blue Origin's Blue Moon lander.

The real reason the catch matters

Catching Ship out of the air is the recovery strategy SpaceX says will enable rapid inspection, refurbishment and reflight — the mechanism behind its hopes for hourly launch cadence.

Musk's biographer Walter Isaacson recalled the December 2020 meeting where Musk first insisted the tower arms could catch a returning Starship, writing on X that 'this is actually a bigger deal for humanity than most people can imagine.'

The coming weeks and months of reuse and refueling tests will show whether the vision holds.

Sources

  1. space.com › What's next for SpaceX's Starship after epic Flight 15 chopsticks catch?
  2. foxbusiness.com › SpaceX makes history as Starship spacecraft caught by launch tower for first time

More on Space