Clancy Holdout Juror Breaks Silence: 'I Didn't Have Any Doubts'

Michael P. Desronvil, the lone holdout in the Lindsay Clancy mistrial, says he never doubted her guilt as his lawyer demands privacy and a retrial looms.

@sharedot

Clancy Holdout Juror Breaks Silence: 'I Didn't Have Any Doubts'

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • True Crime
  • Lindsay Clancy
  • Mistrial
  • Holdout Juror

Michael P. Desronvil, the lone holdout in the Lindsay Clancy mistrial, says he never doubted her guilt as his lawyer demands privacy and a retrial looms.

The holdout speaks

Two weeks after a Massachusetts judge declared a mistrial in the Lindsay Clancy triple-murder trial, the lone holdout juror has broken his silence.

Michael P. Desronvil said in a statement posted to X by his attorney, Edward Andrew Paltzik, "I didn't have any doubts," and that during deliberations he "kept getting cut off as if I had doubts based on the evidence presented."

He added that based on the physical evidence, key witnesses, and what prosecutors presented, he believed it was enough proof that Clancy "knew exactly what she was doing and planned."

Why it contradicts the other 11 jurors

Desronvil's account directly conflicts with what at least five other jurors have told media since the Sept. 4 mistrial.

Three women on the jury — including the foreperson — told NBC Boston that 11 of the 12 jurors had agreed to find Clancy not guilty by lack of criminal responsibility, and that Desronvil wanted to convict but admitted he had expressed doubt in the prosecution's case.

According to NBC News, juror Nick Dargie told "Good Morning America" that Desronvil was often disengaged and scrolling on his phone during deliberations and could not "find something to support his view."

The trial that ended in deadlock

Clancy, a former nurse, was charged with murdering her three children — Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months — by strangling them with exercise bands on Jan. 24, 2023.

Her defense attorney Kevin Reddington argued she was in postpartum psychosis at the time; prosecutors countered that she knew what she was doing and planned the killings in advance.

After nearly 40 hours of deliberation, the foreperson issued deadlock notices twice, and Judge William Sullivan declared a mistrial on Sept. 4 after a third deadlock, with the jury reportedly split 11-1 toward a finding that she was not criminally responsible.

Praise, scrutiny, and a demand for privacy

Desronvil's lawyer, Edward Andrew Paltzik, called his client an "American Hero and Champion of Justice" while stating he would give no interviews — "None. Zero."

Paltzik also asked the public to respect Desronvil's privacy, saying people should "stay away from his home, stop calling him, and don't even think about deciphering his location."

According to Mamamia, Desronvil has faced increasing scrutiny of his personal life, including a restraining order against him at the time of jury selection, an eviction action over $12,000 in unpaid rent, and a 2021 domestic violence accusation that was later dismissed.

Double jeopardy fight and celebrity weight

The stakes now center on whether Clancy faces a second trial. Reddington has filed a motion to drop the charges and has recruited Boston attorney Martin Weinberg — who argued a similar double-jeopardy motion in the Karen Read case — to seek dismissal at a Sept. 29 hearing.

According to Fox News, retired TV judge Judy Sheindlin warned there is "danger" in prosecutors choosing not to retry the case, saying, "There's no question, my dear, that she killed her children. The only question is, is there an excuse for it?"

Sheindlin also called Rep. Nancy Mace's public call for Clancy's execution "ridiculous."

What comes next

Prosecutors for the commonwealth of Massachusetts have not announced whether they will retry Clancy, who remains in custody at Tewksbury Hospital and is due back in court on Sept. 29.

According to Fox News, Reddington said that if prosecutors reduced the top charge to second-degree murder, he would opt for a bench trial without a jury in the hope she would receive probation.

Meanwhile, Clancy's ex-husband Patrick Clancy and his new wife, Dr. Rachel Danis, are set to speak publicly about the case for the first time Sunday on "60 Minutes."

Sources

  1. nbcnews.com › Holdout Lindsay Clancy juror says he didn't have 'any doubts' during contentious deliberations
  2. mamamia.com.au › The Lindsay Clancy jury told one story. The holdout juror just told a very different one.
  3. tmz.com › Lindsay Clancy Juror Says He Had No Reasonable Doubt, Believes She's Guilty
  4. foxnews.com › Judge Judy warns of 'danger' if prosecutors don't retry Lindsay Clancy after murder trial ends in mistrial
  5. aol.com › Judge Judy Makes Her Position Clear on Lindsay Clancy Retrial - AOL

More on True Crime