House Unanimously Holds Leon Black in Contempt Over Epstein Subpoenas
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Politics
- Congress
- Jeffrey Epstein
- Leon Black
The House voted by unanimous consent to hold billionaire Leon Black in contempt of Congress for defying two subpoenas in its Jeffrey Epstein investigation, referring him to the DOJ.
What Happened: A Unanimous Contempt Vote
The House of Representatives on Wednesday approved a resolution holding billionaire Leon Black in contempt of Congress, referring the matter to the U.S. Attorney for the District of Columbia for possible prosecution.
The measure passed by unanimous consent, one day after the House Oversight Committee voted 41-0 to recommend the action.
Black, co-founder and former head of Apollo Global Management, defied two subpoenas — one requiring him to appear for a deposition on Sept. 3 and another requiring him to produce nondisclosure agreements tied to Jeffrey Epstein.
The resolution states that his "willful refusal to comply" constitutes contempt of Congress.
Why the Unanimity Is Surprising
Full-House contempt actions are rare, and rarer still are ones passed with no dissenting voices.
Republicans and Democrats on the Oversight Committee joined in a bipartisan effort, with Chairman James Comer, R-Ky., declaring that "No one is above the law" and Ranking Member Robert Garcia, D-Calif., calling the vote "an important step towards justice and accountability."
Garcia said lawmakers need to know why Black "gave Jeffrey Epstein $180 million dollars." In a polarized Congress, bipartisan agreement to pursue a billionaire over the Epstein probe stands out — Garcia told reporters after the markup that Democrats were "encouraging a swift vote" by the full House.
The Evidence: Defiance and a Walked-Out Interview
According to Roll Call, the committee's report says Black voluntarily participated in a June 26 transcribed interview but refused to answer questions about nondisclosure agreements involving Epstein, Maxwell and himself.
The committee then subpoenaed him to appear for a deposition and produce documents; CBS News reports he submitted only one NDA and skipped the Sept. 3 deposition. Black instead filed a lawsuit in D.C. federal court challenging the subpoenas' validity.
NBC News reports that a 2021 review commissioned by Apollo found Black paid Epstein $158 million between 2012 and 2017 for tax and estate planning advice, while lawmakers have alleged payments totaling $180 million.
The Stakes: DOJ Decision and Black's Defense
The contempt referral leaves the Justice Department to decide whether to seek criminal prosecution of one of the country's wealthiest financiers.
Black's attorneys, Susan Estrich and Aaron Cutler, condemned the action as an "outrageous action that ignores the facts and the truth about Mr. Black" and "a complete abomination," arguing the House acted "without any regard to the active litigation challenging the lawfulness of the Committee's actions."
They called the inquiry politically motivated and noted an ethics complaint against Chairman Comer. Black has denied any wrongdoing and has not been accused of wrongdoing by law enforcement; his lawyers say he "never forced any woman to sign any NDA."
Broader Context: The Epstein Probe Widens
Black is the latest prominent figure drawn into the Oversight Committee's long-running investigation of the federal government's handling of the Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell criminal cases.
According to PBS, others asked to appear have included Bill Clinton and Bill Gates, and Epstein survivors have shared personal accounts of the trafficking enterprise.
The committee's report, per Roll Call, calls Black "one of the individuals most closely connected to Epstein" it has attempted to interview.
What Comes Next
Attention now shifts to two parallel tracks: the Justice Department's decision on whether to prosecute Black for contempt, and Black's lawsuit in D.C. federal court seeking to block the subpoenas for his appearance and the Epstein-related nondisclosure agreements.
His attorneys have asked the Office of Congressional Conduct to probe Chairman Comer's tactics, framing the contempt action as "retaliation" for their client exercising constitutional rights.
Sources
- nbcnews.com › House votes to hold Epstein associate Leon Black in contempt of Congress
- pbs.org › House votes to hold billionaire Leon Black in contempt of Congress over Epstein investigation
- oversightdemocrats.house.gov › Ranking Member Robert Garcia Statement After House Votes to Hold Leon Black in Contempt of Congress
- rollcall.com › Oversight panel recommends holding billionaire Leon Black in contempt
- cbsnews.com › House votes unanimously to hold Epstein business associate Leon Black in contempt of Congress