New Borden Drama Adds Aileen Wuornos Flash-Forward
By @sharedot · · 6 pages
- True Crime
- Lizzie Borden
- Netflix Monster
- Aileen Wuornos
Reality Blurred reports Netflix's Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story includes a Sarah Paulson sequence as Aileen Wuornos that critics call a backdoor pilot.
What the reviews are flagging now
According to Reality Blurred's Sarah D. Bunting, Sarah Paulson appears as Aileen Wuornos in a flash-forward sequence — she notes Wuornos may have used 'Lizzie Borden' as her nom du sex work, but argues she still cannot see why the scene is in the show.
Bunting writes that it plays like a teaser for a future Monster season centered on Wuornos, while praising Paulson for capturing Wuornos's 'antic defiance' and the whipsaw from arrogance to cringing fear to self-loathing.
The casting choices raising eyebrows
Reality Blurred is blunt about the supporting cast: Charlie Hunnam is '25 years too young' to play Andrew Borden, who was 70 the day he died, and the addition of mortuary horror to his storyline is called superfluous.
Rebecca Hall's Abby, the review says, bears no resemblance to the woman most accounts describe as an 'unobjectionable dumpling,' recast as a cartoonishly cruel harpy — though Hall is reportedly having a blast.
On the plus side, Bunting singles out Vicky Krieps's watchable Bridget and Jessica Barden's 'actors-amirite-ing' turn as actress Nance O'Neil, saying the oddball note works. TV Tattle, meanwhile, calls the fourth Monster entry repetitive, with 'all the depth of a papercut.'
Why the fact-bending matters to case fans
The Borden case endures, the review argues, because of the two percent of doubt left after the ninety-eight percent certainty that Lizzie did or didn't do it.
That grey area gives creators Ian Brennan and Max Winkler room to explore theories — possible abuse by Andrew Borden, Lizzie's shoplifting as stockpiling to flee, and her post-acquittal arrangement with Nance O'Neil — without ignoring basic case facts.
Reality Blurred contends the show 'plays infuriatingly loose' with what is known, including victims' ages, vocations, and floor plans, scores Edwardian scenes with The Runaways, and concludes it is not for case aficionados. The verdict on watching: 'Try one ep, LMK how it goes.'
What it means for the Monster franchise
Eight episodes of sensory assault — florid gore, projectile vomit, and graphic depictions of sexual assault, per the Reality Blurred review — may not be the best use of viewers' time, but the franchise's underlying instinct gets a partial defense.
Bunting says Monster and American Crime Story return inevitably to repression, pathology, and the warping effects of homophobia, racism, and misogyny, a worthwhile tack that sometimes produces moving results, as with the Menendez season.
The Wuornos teaser suggests Ryan Murphy's outfit may test whether a Paulson-led season can hold a center that Lizzie's installment, in this review's telling, never gives two consecutive seconds to sit still.