Supreme Court Lets Trump's $400M Ballroom Build Proceed
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Politics
- Supreme Court
- White House
- Donald Trump
A 5-4 Supreme Court ordered that White House ballroom construction can continue indefinitely, rejecting a preservation group's challenge on standing grounds.
What Happened Monday
In a 5-4 vote on Aug. 31, the Supreme Court granted the Trump administration's emergency request, blocking lower-court rulings that would have halted the aboveground portion of the $400 million, 90,000-square-foot ballroom project where the East Wing once stood.
The unsigned order said the National Trust for Historic Preservation, which brought the challenge, likely lacks legal standing to sue, and that lower court judges likely exceeded their authority. The court explicitly did not decide whether the project itself is lawful.
Why the Ruling Surprises
The surprise is Chief Justice John Roberts' vote: he had temporarily allowed construction to continue on Aug. 21, but on Monday he joined the court's three liberal justices in dissent.
Roberts wrote that the construction of the ballroom is likely unlawful because Congress has not approved it, adding that today's decision is no victory for the separation of powers.
His earlier interim order had given the full court time to weigh the administration's bid, making his final alignment against relief a notable reversal.
The Standing Fight
The case turned on a declaration from Alison Hoagland, a preservationist on the National Trust's board who regularly walks past the White House and said she would suffer professional and personal injuries to her aesthetic, cultural and historical interests from a ballroom of the proposed scale.
The majority held that mere offense, disagreement, or distaste does not qualify as a concrete and particularized injury, saying the court had never found standing in such a situation.
Roberts countered that Hoagland, as a historic preservationist, can be aesthetically injured in a concrete, particularized way by the transformation of a historic building she frequently enjoys.
The Evidence in Court Filings
Per court filings cited by CBS News, construction was 65% complete as of Aug. 24, with a 250-person crew working 20 hours a day, seven days a week.
Solicitor General D. John Sauer argued the project, which includes an underground bunker and medical facilities, was vitally required by national security, and officials including the directors of National Intelligence, the Secret Service, the Army and the State Department warned a pause would harm the government.
The White House says $335 million of the expected $400 million has been raised from private donations, an assertion that has been widely disputed, according to NBC News.
What Is at Stake
The National Trust argued the government was trying to outrun the courts, and lower courts had found the project was for Congress to decide, not a matter for Executive self-help.
The plan also includes broader changes to Washington, including a South Lawn helipad and a planned arch larger than the Arc de Triomphe, according to the BBC.
What Comes Next
The lawsuit returns to lower courts, where the underlying question of whether the president can build on the White House grounds without express congressional authority remains undecided.
The administration argues other provisions of federal law allow the president to undertake improvements on the White House grounds, while the trust points to a federal law requiring the express authority of Congress for building on federal land in Washington, D.C.
The decision also lands as the court weighs a separate GOP emergency appeal seeking discounted TV ad rates for party committees ahead of the midterms, per CNN.
Sources
- cnn.com › Supreme Court allows Trump to continue building White House ballroom
- nbcnews.com › Supreme Court allows Trump to move forward with White House ballroom construction
- bbc.com › Supreme Court clears way for Trump to keep building White House ballroom
- cbsnews.com › Supreme Court continues to allow construction of Trump's White House ballroom
- pbs.org › Supreme Court allows White House to continue construction on Trump's $400 million ballroom
- sg.news.yahoo.com › Republicans ask Supreme Court to let them air TV ads for less