Justices Split Signals on Boulder Climate Case, 4-4 Risk

After two hours of argument in Suncor v. Boulder, no clear majority emerged, and Alito's recusal means a 4-4 tie would let the climate suit proceed.

@sharedot

Justices Split Signals on Boulder Climate Case, 4-4 Risk

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Politics
  • Supreme Court
  • Climate Litigation

After two hours of argument in Suncor v. Boulder, no clear majority emerged, and Alito's recusal means a 4-4 tie would let the climate suit proceed.

No majority emerges after two hours of argument

The Supreme Court opened its new term Monday with two hours of argument in Suncor Energy Inc. v. County Commissioners of Boulder County, and came away without a clear direction.

SCOTUSblog reports that after the debate, it was not apparent whether a majority agreed with the energy companies that federal law prohibits Boulder's state-law claims.

Chief Justice John Roberts appeared skeptical of the companies' position, questioning why lawsuits based on out-of-state conduct with in-state effects are treated differently here, while Justice Elena Kagan pressed the companies' lawyer to identify any textual or precedential basis for the constitutional argument.

A ruling is likely months away, with the justices typically taking several months after argument before issuing an opinion.

Alito's recusal sets up a possible 4-4 deadlock

Justice Samuel Alito recused himself from the case, leaving eight justices and raising the prospect of a 4-4 tie. SCOTUSblog reports that a tie would leave the Colorado Supreme Court's ruling in place — the decision that allowed Boulder's lawsuit to move forward.

Alito told the Associated Press that recusal was not required but was a "judgment call" he gave very serious consideration, noting his oil and gas stock came from an inheritance his wife received from her father and that he initially stayed on because he does not own stock in the companies involved.

He decided to step aside as he delved deeper into the substance of the case. Colorado Public Radio notes the Court could also rule that the case is not yet ripe for review, which would likewise let it proceed.

The deception theory and its limits

Boulder's lawyer Kevin Russell argued the suit is not an attempt to regulate emissions but a deception-based claim in the mold of the 1990s tobacco litigation and recent opioid suits, comparing the companies' marketing conduct to those industries.

He told the justices the lawsuit "doesn't prohibit them from engaging in the conduct" but instead requires them to internalize a portion of the cost of their activities.

Justice Amy Coney Barrett tested the theory's limits, asking whether Colorado could pass a law capping greenhouse-gas emissions in the other 49 states; Russell agreed that would be prohibited, distinguishing it from Boulder's compensation claim.

Justice Clarence Thomas pressed on whether the theory would allow suits against large retailers of fossil fuels, and Russell acknowledged that nothing in Boulder's theory prevents that.

Kavanaugh pushes the preemption argument

The most vocal support for the energy companies came from Justice Brett Kavanaugh, who pointed to a line of Supreme Court cases he said "make crystal-clear that interstate air and water pollution are matters for federal law" unless Congress specifies otherwise.

He also warned Boulder's lawyer, according to Grist, that the case could "bankrupt" some oil and gas companies, noting that firms including Suncor have told shareholders the accumulating climate suits could affect their bottom lines.

Companies' attorney Kannon Shanmugam described Boulder's claims as an "unprecedented effort to use state law to regulate global conduct" and warned in rebuttal that the theory would let anyone, including individual climate-affected plaintiffs, sue — joking that Boulder could sue him for refilling his car during an upcoming visit.

Stakes for two dozen similar suits

The outcome reaches far beyond Boulder. An expansive ruling for the companies could also threaten climate Superfund laws passed in Vermont and New York, CPR reports, which require large oil companies to pay damages for the impacts of burning fossil fuels.

Harvard's Erika Kranz told Grist how other cases fare "will depend on how justices write their decision."

What comes next

A decision is expected early next year, with multiple off-ramps available: the Court could uphold the Colorado Supreme Court, find the case premature, or split 4-4 and leave the state ruling in place.

Colorado Public Radio reports that justices Sotomayor and Jackson appeared most interested in the ripeness question — whether the Court can even hear the appeal before any trial or judgment — but SCOTUSblog notes that route received little traction elsewhere.

Even if Boulder survives, CPR notes the case has bounced around lower courts for eight years and would still face procedural hurdles before a jury hears it.

Boulder County Commissioner Marta Loachamin framed the local stakes: "This case is not about asking the courts to solve or even to mitigate the effects of climate change. It is simply about fairness and trying to survive."

Sources

  1. scotusblog.com › Court sends mixed signals on whether it will allow state-tort suits seeking to hold energy companies liable for climate change to go forward
  2. cpr.org › Supreme Court hears Boulder climate case as Trump administration urges court to kill it
  3. newspressnow.com › Alito says Supreme Court can't stem emergency appeals and voices concern over Trump's rhetoric
  4. grist.org › Supreme Court wrestles with who should pay for climate change

More on Politics