Trump Formally Invokes Executive Privilege Over Kennedy Center
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Politics
- Executive Privilege
- Kennedy Center
- Donald Trump
- Joyce Beatty
Trump invoked executive privilege to shield Kennedy Center records from Rep. Joyce Beatty's lawsuit over its planned two-year closure.
What happened
On Wednesday, White House Deputy Counsel Joshua Hoyt told a federal judge that President Trump had formally invoked the presidential communications privilege, a form of executive privilege, in the lawsuit Rep. Joyce Beatty of Ohio brought over the Kennedy Center's planned closure and renovation.
According to CBS News, the invocation covers information, documents, and communications between Trump, his advisers, and Kennedy Center staff about the president's duties and the institution's "effective functioning."
Hoyt argued that without privilege protection, presidential advisers would be "chilled" from giving fully informed recommendations.
Why it is surprising
The claim is untested territory: the Kennedy Center was created by Congress in 1958 and is not part of the executive branch, and Trump is a defendant in the case as chairman of its nonprofit board, a role no sitting president has held before.
Beatty's attorneys, Norm Eisen and Nathaniel Zelinsky, called the move a "cover-up" and a "direct assault on the rule of law," arguing the Supreme Court has stressed privilege should not be invoked lightly.
They note the center "does not exercise executive power" and that Trump voluntarily assumed trustee duties.
The evidence fight
The privilege dispute surfaced during discovery.
NBC News reports that during a deposition of Kennedy Center executive director Matt Floca, a Justice Department lawyer repeatedly instructed him not to answer questions about his conversations with Trump, even suggesting queries about Floca's talks with Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick could violate the privilege.
The Justice Department separately accused Beatty of a "fishing expedition" raising separation-of-powers concerns. The Washington Sun reports the administration says Beatty has already received more than 7,500 pages of documents and participated in five depositions.
The stakes
Beatty is seeking to prove the Trump-aligned board's September vote to close the main building was a fait accompli driven by Trump's February directive to shut the center for two years of renovation.
Trump has said the renovations won't proceed unless he gets "recognition," and was photographed on Air Force One viewing a poster reading "Kennedy Center DEMOLISH," per CBS News. The center remains closed after a September 15 emergency safety assessment.
The New Republic reports the takeover has coincided with a financial collapse, with cash reserves gone and ticket sales plummeting.
The legal arguments clash
The administration argues Trump's involvement "is undoubtedly in his official capacity" because the president has a statutory duty to appoint board members, and that the president is always the president.
Beatty's lawyers counter that trustee and board chair are not presidential roles and that Kennedy Center staff are nothing like the close advisers privilege protects.
According to NBC News, Judge Christopher Cooper has not yet weighed in, but the invocation conflicts with his ruling this month allowing Beatty's team to investigate a photo of Trump viewing the "Kennedy Center DEMOLISH" poster.
What comes next
Judge Cooper now faces a choice, as the Washington Examiner frames it: grant Beatty's motion to compel and reject the privilege claim, or side with the administration and block the communications from her.
Cooper also has pending motions on dissolving his May order blocking the closure, which found the board had not properly weighed the closure's financial and programming impact.
In May he also ordered Trump's name stripped from the building's facade, which crews removed in June, though the front portico has since been covered by a tarp. The privilege ruling will shape whether Beatty's discovery into Trump's role as board chairman can continue at all.
Sources
- cbsnews.com › Trump formally asserts executive privilege in legal fight over Kennedy Center's closure
- washingtonsun.com › Trump Administration Formally Invokes Executive Privilege in Kennedy Center Lawsuit
- nbcnews.com › Trump invokes executive privilege in Kennedy Center court fight
- newrepublic.com › Trump Uses Nuclear Option to Keep Kennedy Center Documents Hidden
- washingtonexaminer.com › Trump invokes executive privilege over Kennedy Center documents