DOJ Subpoenas and State Probe Escalate Alaska Senate Battle
By @sharedot · · 7 pages
- Politics
- US Midterm Elections 2026
- Alaska
- Department Of Justice
Days before midterms, the DOJ issued new subpoenas and Alaska's governor ordered a probe into the second Dan Sullivan ballot scheme.
What happened
The Justice Department has begun issuing a new wave of subpoenas in an ongoing criminal probe of Alaska's US Senate race, according to ABC News, targeting Democratic officials believed to be tied to efforts to recruit Daniel J. Sullivan, a retired teacher, to appear on the ballot alongside Republican incumbent Sen. Dan S. Sullivan.
Separately, Republican Governor Mike Dunleavy directed the state's Department of Public Safety to investigate whether the alleged scheme violated Alaska law and whether criminal charges or civil action are warranted.
"The evidence will determine what happens next," Dunleavy said, adding that anyone found to have broken the law "must be held accountable."
Both moves follow a New York Times report detailing alleged efforts by people connected to Mary Peltola's campaign and senior aides at the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee to recruit spoiler candidates.
Why it is surprising
The escalation is striking on several fronts.
A federal administration is intervening directly in a state election days before voting, with a civil lawsuit seeking to block Alaska from certifying its result if the Trump-backed Sullivan narrowly loses — a case a federal judge is expected to rule on in the coming days.
ABC News also notes that the Justice Department typically avoids overt investigative steps in politically sensitive matters within 60 days of an election, yet Attorney General Todd Blanche downplayed that rule and told Fox News the effort was "cheating" and "fraud."
Meanwhile, Alaska's Supreme Court already affirmed that the non-incumbent Sullivan's candidacy was legal, and election law experts say it is unlikely to be dislodged from the ballot.
The evidence
The New York Times reported that members of Peltola's campaign, her lawyers, and DSCC aides pushed to find a spoiler candidate who could siphon votes from the incumbent senator, relying on text messages, documents, and 12 sources who participated in or were told of the plan — though the BBC has not independently verified that reporting.
ABC News reports the new subpoenas stem from an ongoing criminal probe, with DOJ prosecutors examining whether the behind-the-scenes maneuvering could violate federal conspiracy statutes.
Dunleavy said the reporting substantially supported findings by the Alaska Division of Elections, which investigated similar concerns in June. The Peltola campaign denies any involvement, and both it and the DSCC say they had no connection to Dan J. Sullivan.
The stakes
Alaska is considered by analysts to be one of the tightest races of the upcoming midterms, which will decide which party controls Congress and with it the remaining two years of President Trump's term.
Sen. Sullivan told Fox News that Peltola should "come clean," while Alaska's other Republican senator, Lisa Murkowski, accused the Democratic campaign of a "pattern of lies." Trump has demanded Peltola be barred from the ballot and endorsed the incumbent.
Legal experts, however, are sceptical: Justin Levitt of Loyola Law School noted that "convincing somebody to run for office is not a crime," and Rick Pildes of NYU called the DOJ's civil suit a "frivolous theory" that cites no specific enforcement provision.
Alaska officials have asked a federal court to dismiss it.
What comes next
A federal judge is expected to rule soon on the DOJ's civil lawsuit seeking an injunction against certification, with ABC News reporting that the judge has appeared skeptical of the department's legal maneuvering. Blanche told Fox News he expects more action from the Justice Department this week.
The state's Department of Public Safety investigation will determine whether criminal charges or civil action are warranted, though Dunleavy did not specify which laws he believes may have been violated.
The ballot will list the two men as Dan S Sullivan, the incumbent Republican, and Daniel J Sullivan Jr., and Alaska's ranked-choice system means voters uncertain at the box could select both.
Peltola, who paused campaigning after a car crash that left her family with minor injuries, says no threat will keep her from the race.