Discarded Water Bottle Cracks 1985 Newport Cold Case
By @sharedot · · 6 pages
- True Crime
- Cold Case
- Dna Evidence
DNA from a water bottle left at a Heart tribute band concert tied William Morton to the 1985 murder of Hillary Hellewell, ending a 41-year cold case.
The arrest in a 41-year-old killing
On Oct. 6, William "Billy" Morton, 61, was arrested and charged with first-degree murder in the 1985 killing of 22-year-old Hillary Hellewell in Newport, Rhode Island, according to Fox News.
Hellewell's body was found on a sidewalk along Anthony Street the morning of May 19, 1985, by two brothers heading to work, and a medical examiner determined she died from asphyxia due to strangulation.
Per Fox News, the medical examiner ruled the death a homicide, and evidence preserved at the time — including swabs showing spermatozoa and a soiled blue T-shirt near her head — sat in storage as Newport Police never developed a viable suspect.
Why a concert water bottle broke it open
The surprising turn came in late August, when Fox News reports that senior cold case investigator Michael Nayor of the Rhode Island Attorney General's office followed Morton and his fiancée to a Woonsocket theater for a show by Bad Animals, a Heart tribute band.
Morton bought popcorn and two bottled waters, and when the couple left the show early, the bottle was left behind.
Nayor seized it, and the DNA profile from the bottle matched the partial profiles recovered from stains on Hellewell's pants and the blue shirt, according to the Rhode Island Department of Health as reported by Fox News.
It is a striking echo of the ABC News account in the Nancy Woodrum case, where investigators pulled suspect Carlo Fuentes Flores's DNA off a Coke bottle at a restaurant.
How the case was resurrected
Per Fox News, the case was reviewed in 2004, when DNA profiles for Hellewell and an unknown suspect were entered into the FBI's CODIS database.
A real breakthrough came after 2023, when Rhode Island Attorney General Peter Neronha's office formed a Cold Case Unit and worked with Newport Police and Smithfield Police.
New DNA evaluation at a private lab pinpointed Morton's family line, and investigators learned he had been convicted in 1987 of a violent sexual assault in Newport 45 days after Hellewell's death, an offense that took place a couple of miles from where her body was found.
ABC News describes a similar modern-technology arc in the Woodrum case, where geofencing search warrants served on Google identified a device at the victim's home.
What comes next for Morton — and the pattern
Morton is being held without bond, and Fox News reports the case will go to a grand jury, with a status conference scheduled for Oct. 20; the outlet could not reach his attorney for comment.
The stakes extend beyond one arrest: both stories show investigators increasingly winning cold cases by collecting DNA from items suspects casually discard in public — a theater water bottle in Rhode Island per Fox News, a restaurant Coke bottle in California per ABC News.
The Woodrum parallel shows where such cases can land: Fuentes Flores was found guilty of first-degree murder during a rape and sentenced to life without parole in February 2022, with his appeal denied by the California Court of Appeals in July 2023, according to ABC News.