Trump Lashes Out at Justices After Mail Ballot Defeat
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Politics
- Supreme Court
- Mail Ballots
- 2026 Midterms
Trump attacked the Supreme Court justices he appointed after they rejected his mail ballot restrictions.
What happened
On Monday evening the Supreme Court handed down its decision in United States Postal Service v. California, rejecting President Trump's late-August restrictions on mailed ballots.
According to Vox, the Court's three-sentence order went beyond blocking the rules for 2026, indicating that Trump exceeded his authority and cannot implement such an attack on voting by mail under any circumstances. Even the dissenting justices did not argue the rules were lawful.
On Tuesday, Attorney General Todd Blanche said the administration would comply with the ruling.
Trump's response
Trump did not take the loss quietly. PBS reports that he posted on social media that the justices behaved differently once on the bench than when he had interviewed them during the nominations process.
At a White House Rose Garden briefing, Attorney General Todd Blanche defended the president's public criticism, saying "He is very frustrated" and that Trump "has every right and, indeed, he should communicate his concerns with the Supreme Court whenever he has them."
Blanche insisted the complaints do not undermine the Court's independence, even while confirming the administration would follow the decision.
Why it is surprising
This is a Court where Republicans hold six of nine seats and that has previously ruled Trump may use presidential powers to commit crimes.
Vox reports the Republican majority also last week ordered Missouri to keep its 2024 congressional maps rather than new maps expected to elect seven Republicans and one Democrat.
Vox attributes the pattern to a shift in the cases reaching the Court: as the bench moved right, Republicans brought increasingly brazen legal theories, until the mail ballot effort became so extreme that even most Republican justices balked.
Alito's dissent rested on a procedural argument, not on the rules' legality.
The burden states faced
The rules announced in late August required states to use federally designed, preapproved ballot envelopes and to individually scan mail pieces, a process the administration claimed takes less than a minute per piece.
Vox notes California alone must mail 23 million ballots, which would add up to more than 43 years of scanning.
State election officials described the stakes in human terms: Oregon's Deschutes County Clerk Steve Dennison told OPB the months of legal twists had been "dizzying," and that even a simple envelope redesign for prepaid postage once took all 36 counties months.
Oregon mails ballots to all registered voters on October 14.
The related voter database fight
Less than 24 hours after the mail ballot ruling, the same election-law fight moved to a second front.
According to SCOTUSblog, lawyers for the League of Women Voters and the Electronic Privacy Information Center urged the justices on Tuesday to leave in place a district court ruling blocking the government's use of an overhauled SAVE citizenship database, which a federal judge found violates federal privacy laws and which states are using to remove US citizens from voter rolls based on inaccurate information.
The government argues challengers lack standing; the groups say error-prone verification predictably disenfranchises voters, an effect they say the government concedes is intended.
What comes next
Election officials say voting proceeds as planned this fall, but no one claims the chapter is closed. Dennison told OPB he has no sense of closure and hopes any future change comes with "plenty of runway."
Jefferson County, Colorado announced ballots will go to active registered voters beginning October 5, while noting the underlying legal challenges continue even though the new requirements will not take effect in 2026.
Vox expects Republican lawyers to make more attempts to skew the midterms in coming weeks, but says the USPS decision shows some limits to what this Court will tolerate.
Sources
- vox.com › The Supreme Court has finally had it with Trump's plan to steal the midterms
- pbs.org › WATCH: Blanche justifies Trump bashing Supreme Court over mail ballots: 'He is very frustrated'
- opb.org › Deschutes County clerk reacts to Supreme Court ruling on vote by mail
- scotusblog.com › Groups urge justices to leave in place ruling barring Trump administration's use of voter database
- jeffco.us › Supreme Court Decision Keeps Colorado's Mail Ballot Process on Track