Markey, 80, Crushes Moulton's Generational Challenge in Primary

Senator Ed Markey defeated Representative Seth Moulton by a wide margin in Massachusetts's Democratic Senate primary, rejecting a generational-change campaign.

@sharedot

Markey, 80, Crushes Moulton's Generational Challenge in Primary

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Politics
  • Massachusetts Primary
  • Ed Markey
  • Seth Moulton
  • Democratic Party

Senator Ed Markey defeated Representative Seth Moulton by a wide margin in Massachusetts's Democratic Senate primary, rejecting a generational-change campaign.

Markey turns back the generational wave

In a year that has seen veteran House Democrats felled by younger challengers, Massachusetts voters instead stuck with one of the Senate's longest-serving progressives.

Moulton conceded and pledged to support Markey in November, telling supporters that challenging the establishment is not easy but necessary, and that his campaign started conversations that needed to happen.

The margins: a rout by any measure

The scale of the victory varied depending on the count still coming in, and the numbers should be read as attributed snapshots. Roll Call reported Markey leading 65 percent to 35 percent with 81 percent of the vote in, while the New York Post put the contest at 76 percent to 24 percent.

In House races, Roll Call reported Lynch leading Roath 57 to 43 and Neal leading Whalen 54 to 46 with roughly 90 percent counted, the latter the closest primary of Neal's near-four-decade career. Whatever the final tally, no major incumbent was seriously threatened.

Age became an issue — and backfired

Moulton made Markey's age the centerpiece of his challenge, telling the Boston Globe at his campaign launch that the honest answer to whether Markey was too old was yes, and seizing on a debate stumble in which Markey said he used whatever came up on his iPhone or iPad when asked about artificial intelligence platforms.

In Massachusetts this cycle, age and ideology did not go hand in hand.

Progressives chose the incumbent

The surprise is that the anti-establishment energy ran behind an octogenarian. He also hammered Moulton over his 2024 comments questioning transgender girls' participation in girls' sports, which Moulton later apologized for while stressing his support for the transgender community.

Markey framed the win as a testament to a progressive movement fueled by young people.

Veterans hold the House seats too

The same pattern held in the House, where long-serving Democrats repelled well-funded younger challengers.

Representative Stephen Lynch, 71, in office since 2001, beat 39-year-old lawyer Patrick Roath despite being outraised — Roath brought in about $1.3 million to Lynch's roughly $900,000, per Federal Election Commission filings cited by CNN — and Lynch led by 26 points in a February poll before Roath narrowed the gap to seven.

In the 1st District, 77-year-old Richard Neal, first elected in 1988, defeated 39-year-old teacher Jeromie Whalen, who campaigned on Medicare for All with Our Revolution's backing.

What comes next in November

Because Massachusetts is heavily Democratic, Tuesday's primaries may in effect decide much of the state's congressional delegation.

Markey advances as the heavy favorite against Republican John Deaton, who ran unopposed and lost to Senator Elizabeth Warren by about 20 points in 2024; Markey has pledged that if reelected he will not seek a fourth term.

Former Biden White House aide Dan Koh won the five-way primary for Moulton's open 6th District seat with endorsements from Biden and Kamala Harris, and Roll Call reported he would be the first Asian American to represent Massachusetts in Congress if elected, facing Republican Micah Jones.

Sources

  1. aljazeera.com › Massachusetts primary results: Key takeaways
  2. rollcall.com › Markey coasts to victory over Moulton in Massachusetts primary
  3. nypost.com › Incumbent Ed Markey, 80, defeats Seth Moulton, 47, in Massachusetts Democratic Senate primary
  4. kten.com › Markey fends off generational challenge and other Massachusetts primary takeaways
  5. scrippsnews.com › US Sen. Ed Markey wins Massachusetts Democratic primary over opponent who called for change

More on Politics