How a $30 Abercrombie Was Proven Real, Then Sold for $1.35M

Alderman Merriam's Shells, a 1951 painting, became the first Abercrombie to top $1 million at auction, selling for $1.35M.

@sharedot

How a $30 Abercrombie Was Proven Real, Then Sold for $1.35M

By @sharedot · · 7 pages

  • Art
  • Auctions
  • Gertrude Abercrombie
  • Art Discovery

Alderman Merriam's Shells, a 1951 painting, became the first Abercrombie to top $1 million at auction, selling for $1.35M.

A Dark Hallway Corner and a Signature

According to the outlets' accounts, an anonymous Michigan collector browsing an estate sale in Kalamazoo for records and mid-century furniture spotted a small 8-by-11-inch canvas of nine seashells hanging in a dark hallway corner and bought it for $30 on the strength of its lower-left signature, "abercrombie '51."

Per ArtDependence and Gulf News, the painting had been out of public view for roughly 75 years after Abercrombie gave it to Dr. John Reynolds of Kalamazoo in exchange for medical services, and it stayed with his family until this year's rediscovery.

The Milwaukee Catalogue Clue

The evidence that transformed the purchase came, the reports say, from an exhibition.

Gulf News and The Times of India describe how the buyer changed his family holiday plans to visit the Gertrude Abercrombie retrospective The Whole World Is a Mystery at the Milwaukee Art Museum, where the catalogue reproduced a 1952 Chicago Tribune photograph showing the painting in its original frame beside the actual shells it depicts.

Recognizing that Freeman's had sponsored the Milwaukee exhibition, the owner entrusted the work to the auction house, according to ArtDependence.

Scholar Authentication and the Estimate

Dr. Susan Weininger, described across the pack as the leading Abercrombie scholar and a professor emerita of art history at Roosevelt University, examined the painting and authenticated it.

Painted in 1951, the work shows nine seashells on a slate-gray surface with a single conical shell suspended by a thread against a black wall; the shells belonged to Robert Merriam, alderman of Hyde Park.

Per the pack, it appeared in six solo shows in 1952 and 1953 before vanishing, and Freeman's estimated it at just $150,000 to $250,000.

Why Art Historians Care About the Shells

Beyond the price, the outlets highlight an art-historical payoff: as the auction house put it in the pack's reporting, the work is a rare instance of Abercrombie painting directly from life, confirming that the shell motif in her later solitary shell paintings — long presumed invented — was drawn from observation and memory.

The story also fits a market pattern the pack situates alongside other dramatic auction results, with bidding on October 1 drawing five telephone bidders and several online buyers before the hammer fell at $1.06 million, reaching $1,352,600 with premium.

A Storybook Ending, and What Comes Next

The result marks the first Abercrombie ever to cross $1 million, a new world auction record for the Chicago Surrealist.

Zack Wirsum, Freeman's Senior Vice President and Head of Post War & Contemporary Art, called it the happily-ever-after to the fairytale and praised the "eagle-eyed consignor who saved this masterpiece from staying forever lost to time," adding that strong results across the rest of the sale added to the day.

The buyer, per the pack, remains anonymous — rewarded for trusting his eye.

Sources

  1. artdependence.com › From $30 Estate Sale Discovery to $1.35 Million: Abercrombie's Shells Sets New Auction Record
  2. gulfnews.com › He paid $30 for a painting at a Michigan estate sale. It sold for $1.35 million
  3. timesofindia.indiatimes.com › A Michigan collector paid $30 for a seashell painting at an estate sale; it was later identified as a 1951 Gertrude Abercrombie work

More on Art