High Court Clears Trump Mail Vote Order
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Politics
- Supreme Court
- Voting Rights
- Elections
- Mail In Voting
The 6-3 ruling lifts an injunction but leaves door open for new challenges before midterms.
What the Court Decided
The Supreme Court's 6-3 conservative majority on Monday lifted an injunction issued by U.S. District Judge Indira Talwani that had blocked key provisions of President Donald Trump's March executive order on mail-in voting in 23 states and Washington, D.C.
The court ruled that the states, led by California, sued prematurely before federal agencies had finalized implementation plans. The decision did not address whether the executive order itself is constitutional.
According to SCOTUSblog, the majority characterized the order's provisions as internal directives that had not yet caused states the kind of concrete injury required to sue.
A Narrow Ruling With an Explicit Warning
The majority's unsigned opinion emphasized that its decision was limited to the procedural question of timing, not the merits of the order.
"The Court's disposition of this application does not mean that any measure taken by the Government to implement the Order will necessarily be lawful," the majority wrote. "On that score, time will tell."
NPR reports that the ruling focused on the ability of the mostly Democratic-led states to challenge Trump's order when they did, rather than on the order's legality. The opinion explicitly left the door open for new challenges once federal agencies take concrete steps to implement the order.
What the Executive Order Would Do
Trump's executive order, signed in March, directed the Department of Homeland Security to compile lists of adult U.S. citizens eligible to vote in each state. It directed the attorney general to prioritize prosecution of state and local election officials who issue ballots to ineligible voters.
The order also required the U.S. Postal Service to deliver mail-in ballots only to voters on approved state lists and to create new ballot envelope design standards. SCOTUSblog reports that the order instructed DHS to send citizenship lists to states at least 60 days before a federal election.
The Postal Service issued its final implementing rule last week.
Liberal Justices Issue Strong Dissents
The court's three liberal justices dissented. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson accused the majority of "taking its eye off the ball" and missing what she called the government's "actual objective: to secure our imprimatur for its effort to foment chaos ahead of the November elections."
She described the ruling as another chapter "in the Kafkaesque nightmare that our precedents have been steadily creating for certain plaintiffs who seek to bring election-related challenges."
Justice Sonia Sotomayor, joined by Justice Elena Kagan, wrote that the decision "merely postpones adjudication of those challenges" and does not suggest the executive branch has constitutional authority to implement the directives.
Remaining Hurdles and State Pushback
A separate nationwide injunction issued by Judge Talwani on August 11 remains in effect, blocking the USPS from enforcing the order's mail voting rules across all states.
Votebeat reports that this injunction stemmed from a case brought by voting-rights groups led by the League of Women Voters, and that the Supreme Court did not address it in Monday's ruling. California Gov. Gavin Newsom vowed that his state "will be suing AGAIN to block these Orwellian rules."
Oregon officials, including Secretary of State Tobias Read and Attorney General Dan Rayfield, assured voters that November elections will proceed as planned. According to KATU, Read said the ruling "was about the timing of our lawsuit against the president's executive order, not about the merits."
What Comes Next
The Supreme Court's opinion explicitly states that "if the Postal Service's final rule harms the States, they may challenge that rule."
The USPS unveiled its final rule last week, and according to OPB, California's attorney general, who led the initial lawsuit, is already promising another challenge. Notre Dame law professor Derek Muller described the situation as "just the first inning of a very fast nine-inning game."
Yahoo reports that North Carolina is set to send ballots to overseas and military voters on September 4, with other states following shortly after, leaving little time for major changes before November.
Sources
- scotusblog.com › Supreme Court allows Trump administration to move forward with order imposing restrictions on mail-in voting
- nbcnews.com › Supreme Court hands preliminary win to Trump on mail-in ballots executive order
- yahoo.com › Supreme Court sides with Trump administration on mail voting restrictions ahead of midterms
- npr.org › Supreme Court gives Trump an interim win on his mail voting order, but hurdles loom
- jpost.com › US Supreme Court lifts a judicial hurdle to Trump's mail-in ballot curbs
- votebeat.org › Supreme Court sides with Trump over mail-voting restrictions — but they still might not affect the midterms
- kcra.com › Gov. Newsom vows new lawsuit after Supreme Court ruling on mail-in ballot order
- opb.org › Oregon Democrats say they'll keep fighting mail voting order, following Supreme Court ruling