Trump Bars CNN, MS NOW and Politico From White House

Journalists from three major outlets were physically denied entry and had badges seized after Trump banned them for 'fake news' coverage.

@sharedot

Trump Bars CNN, MS NOW and Politico From White House

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Politics
  • Press Freedom
  • White House
  • Donald Trump

Journalists from three major outlets were physically denied entry and had badges seized after Trump banned them for 'fake news' coverage.

What Happened

Reporters from CNN, MS NOW and Politico were denied access to the White House grounds on Saturday morning, a day after President Trump announced on Truth Social that the three outlets were banned for reporting what he called "FICTION and LIES."

MS NOW's Akayla Gardner said an officer asked her to hand over her badge because it was "disabled" and could not explain why. CNN's Betsy Klein said a Secret Service agent deactivated her badge, and Politico reported that Cheyenne Haslett was turned away and had her pass confiscated.

Why It's Surprising

This is not a symbolic spat but an actual physical exclusion: credentialed, long-serving journalists were turned away at the gate and had badges physically seized. Betsy Klein has covered the White House since the Obama administration, yet a Secret Service agent took her badge with no explanation.

Trump also openly floated expanding the ban, saying "the New York Times is fake news, the Washington Post is fake news" when asked who might be next.

A ban affecting three major outlets simultaneously, enforced on the ground within a day, goes beyond earlier access disputes like the AP Gulf of Mexico case.

The Evidence

Multiple outlets independently confirmed the exclusions. Al Jazeera reports that MS NOW reporter Akayla Gardner, CNN's Betsy Klein and Politico's Cheyenne Haslett were photographed together outside the White House complex after being denied entry and having credentials deactivated or confiscated.

Trump defended the move himself, telling reporters at a press conference, "No, no, no, no. I dislike dishonest press," and saying the ban exists "because they are fake news," while adding the outlets could be restored if they "straighten out."

He said the frustration had built up over two years rather than stemming from any single article.

The Constitutional Stakes

First Amendment advocates say the ban is flatly unconstitutional. Al Jazeera reports that a 1977 federal appeals court ruling, Sherrill v Knight, found the White House cannot deny access arbitrarily once it establishes press facilities for credentialed journalists.

Jameel Jaffer of the Knight First Amendment Institute called excluding journalists from the press pool, a public forum, "doubly unconstitutional" when done on the basis of viewpoints.

White House Correspondents' Association President Jacqui Heinrich, of Fox News, demanded immediate restoration of access, and Theodore Boutrous told NPR the ban is, on its face, unconstitutional.

The Outlets Fight Back

All three banned organizations say they will keep covering the president and defend their rights.

CNN called the ban "an illegal assault" on constitutionally protected reporting, while MS NOW said the White House "belongs to the American people" and pledged to take "any and all steps necessary" to defend the First Amendment.

Politico's editor-in-chief Jonathan Greenberger said the outlet stands by Haslett and will vigorously defend its rights. The Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press told the BBC it expects the ban to be struck down quickly by the courts because it is "flatly unconstitutional."

What Comes Next

Legal challenges appear imminent, with Al Jazeera's reporting indicating the ban will likely be contested soon, though it is unclear exactly how courts would apply the Sherrill precedent to revoked existing credentials.

The standoff lands in a consequential stretch: amid a midterm season where Democrats hold an edge, Trump faces pushback over the unpopular Middle East war and an affordability crisis, and he is set to host China's Xi Jinping and address the UN General Assembly this week.

The WHCA warns the precedent could let any future administration exclude any outlet over unfavorable coverage.

Sources

  1. npr.org › CNN, MS NOW, Politico reporters denied access to White House following Trump ban
  2. aljazeera.com › A 'ban on the free press': White House bars journalists from three outlets
  3. bbc.com › CNN, MS NOW and Politico say reporters denied White House access after Trump banned some media outlets
  4. scrippsnews.com › Trump says CNN, MS NOW and Politico are banned from White House for 'fake news'

More on Politics