California Sues USPS Over Ballot Rules

California and allied states filed a new federal suit after the Postal Service issued final rules.

@sharedot

California Sues USPS Over Ballot Rules

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Politics
  • Elections
  • Supreme Court
  • Mail Voting

California and allied states filed a new federal suit after the Postal Service issued final rules.

What Happened

Just days after the U.S. Supreme Court gave President Trump a procedural win on his mail-in voting executive order, California Attorney General Rob Bonta announced a new lawsuit aimed at protecting state authority over election administration.

The suit, filed in federal court in Massachusetts on Wednesday, makes good on Gov. Gavin Newsom's pledge to sue again immediately after the Supreme Court decision, according to reporting originally published by CalMatters.

Why the Timing Changed

The high court's majority had essentially ruled that California sued too early, noting the administration had not yet issued formal rules affecting voting.

That changed late last week when the U.S. Postal Service issued final rules requiring states to turn over lists of eligible mail voters, redesign ballot envelopes with USPS approval, and include new tracking barcodes. Those concrete rules make the challenge ripe in a way the earlier filing was not.

The Rules at Issue

Under Trump's order, the Postal Service would not deliver ballots to voters who are not in a federal database the administration wants to build, and would not deliver ballots in states that do not comply with its rules.

A federal judge has currently blocked the order from taking effect, per the Tallahassee Democrat, which reports the dispute will likely ultimately reach the U.S. Supreme Court.

The Stakes for Voters

More than 89% of California voters used mail-in ballots in the latest June primary, so any disruption would be enormous there.

In Florida, election officials tell the Tallahassee Democrat the Nov. 3 election will not be disrupted: ballots are being prepared in all 67 counties, with an Oct. 22 deadline to request one, and over 1.2 million mail ballots were cast in the Aug. 18 primary.

Brookings Institution research, cited by the Tallahassee Democrat, found mail-voting fraud cases account for only about 0.000043% of mail ballots cast.

A Constitutional Clash

Bonta called the Postal Service rules a "clear violation of the Constitution," which designates states as the primary authority over elections, saying "President Trump doesn't get to rewrite our voting system on a whim."

In a column published by chronicleonline.com, UC Berkeley Law dean Erwin Chemerinsky argues Trump has no constitutional authority over elections and that Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson's dissent warned against letting the Executive proceed even one step further.

What Comes Next

Given its challenges in court, it is unclear whether the Postal Service's new rule will affect the November elections, CalMatters reporting states.

Sean Freeder of the University of North Florida, quoted by the Tallahassee Democrat, says changing longstanding mail-voting practices weeks before ballots go out would be "far too chaotic," though the issue could resurface in future elections under intense legal scrutiny.

With midterms less than three months away, courts face pressure to move quickly.

Sources

  1. timesofsandiego.com › California sues to block Trump's mail-in voting rules just days after loss at Supreme Court
  2. laist.com › Mail-in voting rules
  3. chronicleonline.com › The Supreme Court needs to remind Trump he has no power over elections
  4. tallahassee.com › Florida mail voting on track despite Trump's attempt to limit method

More on Politics