Hoskins Defies Missouri Court, Faces Contempt Over Map
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Politics
- Missouri Gerrymander
- Election Law
Missouri's secretary of state ordered the GOP map used despite a state court injunction, and now faces a contempt hearing after asking a federal judge to shield him.
What Happened
Missouri Secretary of State Denny Hoskins defied a unanimous state supreme court injunction by telling local election officials to use the 2025 Republican-drawn congressional map in November.
The Missouri Supreme Court issued an unusual late-night order Tuesday demanding Hoskins appear in person at a 10 a.m. Thursday hearing to explain why his email to local officials "is not an affirmative violation of this court's injunction."
Hoskins then filed a last-minute request with Chief U.S. District Judge Stephen Clark asking him to block the state court's contempt hearing entirely.
Why He Says He Can Defy the State Court
Hoskins argues that Clark's federal ruling "takes precedence over the Missouri Supreme Court's order."
According to the Missouri Independent, Hoskins's attorney Lou Capozzi of the attorney general's office wrote that "so long as the district court's order stands, the secretary must obey it," and warned against "the radical step of holding the secretary of state in contempt for following a federal court order."
Democracy Docket reports that Hoskins told the state supreme court that unless a higher court issues a stay of the federal order, he cannot disregard it without exposing himself to federal contempt proceedings.
The Colliding Court Orders
Tuesday's chaos began when Justice Brett Kavanaugh denied Hoskins's emergency Supreme Court application in a six-word order, seemingly leaving in place the Missouri Supreme Court's ruling that the 2025 gerrymander never legally took effect and must go before voters as Proposition A. Minutes later, Clark issued a temporary restraining order in a separate lawsuit filed by U.S. Rep. Bob Onder, state Sen. Rick Brattin and two voters, blocking Hoskins from using any map other than the 2025 GOP map.
Vox reports that Clark's opinion even acknowledges Kavanaugh's denial of the very same victory moments earlier, and that the case is now on appeal to the Eighth Circuit.
Why It's Surprising
It is extraordinary for a sitting secretary of state to be summoned to explain contempt by his state's highest court while simultaneously asking a federal judge for protection from that same court.
Hoskins spent the past year rejecting the referendum petition, according to Democracy Docket, which reports he photographed himself with a baseball bat while trying to thwart voters' veto referendum.
The state supreme court then found unanimously that his delay in ruling on the petitions created the very confusion he complained about, with Judge Ginger Gooch calling his timing argument "particularly misplaced," according to Vox.
The Stakes for November
With ballots due to be finalized and printed under imminent deadlines, local election officials now face conflicting marching orders from state and federal courts.
The 2025 GOP gerrymander dismantles a Kansas City district represented by Rep. Emanuel Cleaver as part of a national push for more Republican House seats, per Democracy Docket.
Vox notes it is a terrible time to be an election official, with administrators expecting competing court orders and shifting rules just two months before the midterm elections, and it remains unclear which map Missouri must actually use.
What Comes Next
Three tracks remain live: Clark set a 5 p.m.
Wednesday deadline for People Not Politicians to respond to Hoskins's request and did not immediately rule; People Not Politicians is separately seeking Eighth Circuit review of Clark's restraining order; and the state supreme court's contempt hearing remains set for Thursday morning, with Hoskins ordered to appear in person.
The outcome will likely turn on whether Clark or the appeals court allows the state injunction to be enforced, and on how courts weigh Hoskins's claim that federal orders leave the state court powerless over him.
Sources
- missouriindependent.com › Denny Hoskins asks federal judge to block Missouri Supreme Court contempt hearing
- democracydocket.com › Missouri election chief asks federal judge to shield him from contempt charges after defying state supreme court
- vox.com › Republicans suffered a stunning Supreme Court loss. It lasted minutes.