Officials Say They Can't Comply With USPS Mail Ballot Rule

Election officials say they can't meet USPS mail ballot rules this fall because vendors can't reprint envelopes in time.

@sharedot

Officials Say They Can't Comply With USPS Mail Ballot Rule

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Politics
  • Mail In Voting
  • Usps
  • 2026 Midterms

Election officials say they can't meet USPS mail ballot rules this fall because vendors can't reprint envelopes in time.

What Happened

With weeks before ballots go out, election officials across the country are telling courts and reporters that the Postal Service's proposed mail voting rules cannot actually be implemented.

In court filings and interviews with CNN, officials and mail voting experts said there is no practical way to comply with the plans — even if states could find the millions of dollars compliance is expected to cost.

Vendors say there is not enough time to print the millions of envelopes that would need redesigning, and court filings suggest there may not even be enough paper stock.

Colorado's Jefferson County, which sends 433,000 mail ballots, is among the jurisdictions caught in limbo as the rule sits on hold under a temporary federal court order that the administration is appealing.

Why It's Surprising

The administration has described the new postal rules as a 'modest' change for states, but the practical barriers described by officials are enormous.

According to CNN, Washington Elections Director Stuart Holmes said in court filings that reprinting would cost nearly $2 million there, with more than 1 million envelopes needing replacement — and none of the state's three major mail ballot vendors could confirm they could do the work in time, cost aside.

Oregon Elections Director Dena Dawson added in a filing that vendors have no stockpile of paper and post-pandemic supply shortages mean suppliers may not deliver what is needed. With jurisdictions nationwide ordering reprints at once, officials expect the choke point only to worsen.

The Evidence

The scale of the approval problem is documented in state court declarations.

According to CNN, Vermont Secretary of State Sarah Copeland Hanzas said approval of Vermont's 494 ballot envelope styles took about three months of routine work with USPS, after which the agency requested changes to 247 styles.

Michigan, per its elections director's declaration, has 1,521 different envelope types that would need review. USPS is believed to have only around 40 Mailpiece Design Analysts, and the new regulation asserts no additional staff are needed.

Separately, a whistleblower report released Tuesday and submitted by Sen. Richard Blumenthal alleges USPS allotted just a few days to test its haphazardly built voter-data portal, with a 'zero-percent failure policy' that could reject entire batches of ballots if a single envelope fails to match.

The Stakes

If states or local officials fail to meet the requirements, USPS will not deliver their ballots — risking mass disenfranchisement.

Colorado's secretary of state's office estimates the data upload process would add tens of thousands of hours of staff work statewide, because its registration database does not currently record the envelope bar codes that would need manual entry into the portal.

Arizona Secretary of State Adrian Fontes warned in a court declaration the portal may not handle a bulk upload for Maricopa County's 2.5 million voters, citing past crashes in a separate federal system.

'These aren't minor implementation details — they determine whether millions of eligible voters get their ballots,' Jefferson County Clerk Amanda Gonzalez told CNN.

The Pushback

The White House dismissed the concerns, saying states should have been prepared since the proposal rolled out months ago.

'Any confusion was caused by radical Democrats' litigation to stop these commonsense measures that protect the security of mail-in ballots and ensure only Americans are electing American leaders,' White House spokeswoman Lauren Bis said, per CNN.

A USPS spokesperson said the agency is 'carefully reviewing' the whistleblower's concerns and that the portal has been developed 'in a manner consistent with court orders.'

Sen. Blumenthal, per NPR, urged Postmaster General David Steiner to abandon what he called an 'ill-conceived, unconscionable plan,' while House Oversight Democrats led by Rep. Robert Garcia demanded documents on the portal's development.

What Comes Next

The mandates are currently on hold under a temporary federal court ruling that the administration is appealing to the 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, and the issue is expected to reach the Supreme Court again now that a final plan has been announced.

NPR reports voting by mail for the midterms officially starts this week, and a federal judge in Boston found the plan likely illegal because USPS has no authority to control voting by mail.

Officials anticipate a legal rollercoaster of the order being revived and blocked again, but with November fixed, they say the practical hurdles have become insurmountable.

Nevada Secretary of State Cisco Aguilar said he is 'nervous' after the whistleblower disclosures but that he and other Democratic secretaries of state will 'not relent' in letting the administration dictate election administration.

Sources

  1. cnn.com › Election officials say they can't comply with Trump's proposed mail ballot rules
  2. npr.org › USPS 'carefully reviewing' whistleblower claim on plan for Trump's mail in voting order
  3. newrepublic.com › Whistleblower Warns USPS Has Secret Plan to Undo Mail-In Voting
  4. jezebel.com › USPS Whistleblower Warns of 'Catastrophic Failure' Coming in Post Office Mail Ballot Processing

More on Politics