107,000 Texts Take Over Flynn Murder Trial

Testimony in Caleb Flynn's murder trial put 107,000 text messages and explicit death wishes at the center of an Ohio staged-home-invasion case.

@sharedot

107,000 Texts Take Over Flynn Murder Trial

By @sharedot · · 6 pages

  • True Crime
  • Caleb Flynn
  • Murder Trial
  • Text Messages

Testimony in Caleb Flynn's murder trial put 107,000 text messages and explicit death wishes at the center of an Ohio staged-home-invasion case.

What the trial is about

Caleb Flynn, 40, is charged in Miami County Common Pleas Court with aggravated murder, two counts of felonious assault and three counts of tampering with evidence in the death of his wife, Ashley Flynn.

The Springfield News-Sun reports she was a middle school volleyball coach and educator, a mother of two daughters, and was shot twice in the head as she slept early on Monday, Feb. 16, at the family's Tipp City home — about a week before her 38th birthday.

The scene, according to the paper's trial coverage, was apparently staged to look like a home invasion. Flynn is a music pastor and former "American Idol" contestant.

Why the text trove stunned the courtroom

The surprising development inside the trial is the sheer volume of the record: roughly 107,000 text messages exchanged over a year between Flynn and former mistress Alleigha Botner.

Per the Springfield News-Sun, printouts were bound into about three dozen books stored in three cardboard boxes wheeled into the courtroom. Prosecutor Paul Watkins had Botner read dozens aloud, and she became emotional before one exchange.

"I want to kill her, Caleb," she read, adding she then wrote "so bad" — and that Flynn replied, "that makes two of us." Botner admitted she twice feared for Ashley Flynn and told jurors she now says, "I hate him" and "I believe that he murdered his wife."

On cross-examination she agreed she sent twice as many texts as Flynn.

The timeline jurors are hearing

The Springfield News-Sun reports the relationship frayed after an August 2025 anniversary cruise, when Ashley Flynn found texts from Botner on her husband's phone. Botner set repeated deadlines for Flynn to leave his wife, texting in late October, "until she's gone, I'm gone."

The final deadline was Jan. 11. On the night of Sunday, Feb. 15 — hours before the killing — Botner testified the two drafted a checklist for the next day: a burner phone, a talk with Flynn's father-in-law, and a possible job and place to stay.

She said she sent ChatGPT screenshots about no-fault divorce and custody, and advice on permanently deleting messages. FBI special agent Andrea Kinzig testified there was no information on Ashley Flynn's iPhone indicating an extramarital affair.

Family shock, the defense — and what's next

Ashley Flynn's family says the death and the affair blindsided them. The Springfield News-Sun reports Todd Smith, her father and Flynn's boss, testified nothing about the home-invasion story made sense, wondering aloud how the family's goldendoodles — which slept in the room — did not "go bananas."

Sister Kayla Keyt said she had "not an inkling" of the affair and initially told police they had the wrong man; she is now raising the girls. Defense attorneys L. Patrick Mulligan and Emily Smith argue the only evidence against their client is the affair, and adultery is not proof of homicide.

In a parallel courtroom shock the same week, ABC News reports Luigi Mangione's state murder trial was adjourned after he pleaded guilty to federal stalking counts and admitted shooting UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson, with his attorneys now moving to dismiss the state charges under New York's double jeopardy law.

Sources

  1. springfieldnewssun.com › Caleb Flynn murder trial: What to know this week
  2. abcnews.com › Luigi Mangione's state murder trial adjourned

More on True Crime