Trump Asks Supreme Court to Let USPS Enforce Ballot Rules
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Politics
- Supreme Court
- Elections
- Mail Voting
The Trump administration filed an emergency Supreme Court appeal Thursday seeking to lift a federal judge's block on new USPS mail ballot rules weeks before the midterms.
What Happened: An Emergency Appeal Straight to the Justices
The Trump administration asked the Supreme Court on Thursday to allow the US Postal Service to enforce sweeping new restrictions on mail-in voting, less than two months before the November midterm elections.
According to CNN, the emergency appeal leapfrogged lower courts still considering the case and seeks to lift a federal judge in Boston's temporary order blocking the plan.
The Justice Department asked the justices to step in immediately with a short-term order letting USPS implement its new regulations, which the administration described as "only modest envelope-design and addressee-information requirements." The court requested a response by Tuesday morning.
Why It Is Surprising: Racing Against Ballots Already in the Mail
The timing is extraordinary. North Carolina begins mailing absentee ballots on Friday, officially kicking off the midterm voting season, and a few Wisconsin municipalities already sent ballots earlier this week.
PBS reports that US District Court Judge Indira Talwani said Thursday that USPS had told her nothing about how it would implement the plan, telling the Justice Department lawyer, "We are 70 days from the election and I have nothing from the USPS about how this will happen."
Most election offices have already printed their envelopes and ballots, and the online portal states would be required to use was still not active this week, according to PBS.
The Evidence: What the New Rules Would Require
Under the regulations tied to Trump's March executive order, states would have to submit lists of eligible mail voters to USPS through an online portal, and the Postal Service would decline to deliver ballots to any voter whose name does not appear on that list.
The rule would also require unique bar codes for each voter on election mail envelopes. NPR reports that USPS issued the revised federal ballot mail rule in August and says it would not deliver ballots for election officials who do not meet the requirements.
The March order also directs DHS and the Social Security Administration to build a nationwide list of eligible voters, according to the Scripps News Group.
The Stakes: Whistleblower Warns of Millions of Lost Ballots
The fight carries enormous stakes for mail voting, which roughly 29% of voters used in 2024 according to the US Election Assistance Commission figure cited by Flint Beat.
A whistleblower report made public this week alleges USPS is rushing an untested plan that could reject entire batches of ballots if a single envelope's bar code registers an error, potentially throwing out tens of thousands of legitimate ballots at once and leaving millions of Americans without their ballots.
Election officials in the 23 Democratic-led states challenging the order argue the Constitution gives states, not the president, the power to run elections.
The Legal Battlefield So Far
The Supreme Court has already touched this fight once. In August, NPR notes, the justices ruled on a procedural question and cleared the way for the administration to keep working on the executive order, but have not ruled on its legality.
Judge Talwani then blocked the plan in Boston, and the administration appealed. The Justice Department argues USPS has broad authority to change mail protocols, pointing to past changes covering cremated remains and replica explosives, per CNN.
Solicitor General D. John Sauer urged the high court to take the case despite the normally unappealable nature of a temporary restraining order.
What Comes Next: A Speedy Timeline for the Court
The 6-3 conservative court now faces pressure to decide one of the most significant election questions in years on an unusually fast timeline, with responses due Tuesday morning and three liberal justices having dissented from the August ruling.
The administration will first need to clear the procedural hurdle of appealing a temporary restraining order.
Meanwhile, voters can still request and cast mail ballots as usual — NPR confirms that voting by mail remains available to all eligible voters and USPS is expected to deliver midterm ballots as normal while the case proceeds.
Sources
- cnn.com › Trump asks Supreme Court to OK sweeping changes for mail ballots
- pbs.org › Federal judge considers whether to extend ban against U.S. Postal Service mail voting changes
- npr.org › Trump asks Supreme Court to lift block on USPS plan to restrict mail voting
- abc15.com › Trump administration asks Supreme Court to allow mail-in voting limits before midterms
- flintbeat.com › Election law experts breaks down Supreme Court ruling on mail voting restrictions