$30 Estate-Sale Abercrombie Painting Sells for $1.3M
By @sharedot · · 6 pages
- Art
- Auctions
- Gertrude Abercrombie
- Surrealism
A painting bought for $30 at a Michigan estate sale turned out to be Gertrude Abercrombie's lost 1951 work, setting an artist record at auction.
A $30 Hallway Find Becomes a $1.3 Million Masterpiece
In 2025, a collector browsing a "picked over" estate sale in Kalamazoo, Michigan spotted a small painting in a dimly lit hallway near the garage, according to All That's Interesting.
He could barely make out the inscription — "abercrombie '51" — but knew the name, bought it for $30, and brought it to the Milwaukee Art Museum, which was running an Abercrombie survey.
Its catalog held a historical photograph of the work, prompting the owner to consult Susan Weininger, an Abercrombie expert, who confirmed the painting as the original *Alderman Merriam's Shells*.
At Freeman's auction, it sold for $1.3 million — far above the $200,000 pre-sale estimate and a record for the artist.
The Painting's Strange 75-Year Journey
All That's Interesting traces the work's history in remarkable detail. Abercrombie painted the 8×11-inch oil in late 1951, using shells lent by Robert Merriam, Chicago's fifth-ward alderman, whose ward included her Hyde Park neighborhood.
She soon gave the painting to Dr. John T. Reynolds of Kalamazoo as payment for a 1952 operation. Reynolds loaned it to exhibitions in New York, Chicago and Milwaukee in 1952 and 1953, and it was offered for $50 to $150 — but nobody bought it.
A note on the back from those loans helped document its history.
"I'm not interested in complicated or commonplace subjects. Instead, I like to paint simple things that are a little strange," Abercrombie once said, per the outlet — and the painting shows nine realistic shells arranged strangely, one suspended above a dark void.
From 'Jazz Witch' to Titan of American Surrealism
The record sale caps a decade-long revival in Abercrombie's reputation. All That's Interesting reports she was self-taught, trained in Romance languages at the University of Illinois, worked in advertising and Sears drawing, and got her first one-woman show at the Chicago Art Institute in 1944.
In the early 1950s financial pressure pushed her to produce many small paintings, some made into pins and brooches and sold at local art fairs.
Known as the "Queen of Chicago" for hosting Midwest artists in her Hyde Park brownstone, and the "jazz witch" for her peaked hat and friendships with Dizzy Gillespie and Charlie Parker, she reached a global audience only with a 2018 exhibition, the outlet notes.
Eighty of her paintings have now sold above $100,000, with this sale the crown jewel.
The Stakes: Seven-Figure Collectibles Face Tax Limbo
For collectors eyeing the next such windfall, 24/7 Wall St. highlights a legal gray zone: the federal definition of a "collectible" under 26 U.S.C. § 408(m)(2) lists works of art, rugs, antiques, metals, gems, stamps, coins and alcoholic beverages — but not trading cards, and the outlet notes the code predates Pokémon (1996) and Magic: The Gathering (1993).
Long-term collectibles gain faces a maximum 28% rate under § 1(h), while gains outside the definition are taxed at 0%, 15% or 20%. The publication says sellers must adopt a defensible reading, with the catch-all clause awaiting Treasury guidance.
A painting like Abercrombie's clearly fits the art category, but the outlet's reporting shows heirs and sellers of any rising collectible should keep purchase receipts and grading bills to document cost basis.