Missouri Court Weighs Referendum on GOP House Map
By @sharedot · · 7 pages
- Politics
- Missouri Redistricting
- Referendum
- Elections
The Missouri Supreme Court heard arguments Wednesday on whether voters get a referendum on the GOP-drawn congressional map, with a ruling due by Tuesday.
What happened in Jefferson City
The Missouri Supreme Court heard arguments Wednesday in three referendum cases, the most consequential of which decides whether the congressional map state lawmakers passed last year goes to a public vote.
According to STLPR, two of the three issues must be resolved by Tuesday, the deadline for court-ordered additions to appear on the November 3 ballot. If the court reverses Circuit Judge Daniel Green's ruling from last month, the referendum would go to voters and the new map could be suspended.
Why the arguments matter
The clash turns on competing readings of the state constitution. Attorney Chuck Hatfield, arguing for referendum supporters, told the court the plain language gives the people a right to a referendum on any act of the General Assembly.
Solicitor General Lou Capozzi countered that a separate provision stating no redistricting plan shall be subject to the referendum resolves the case, arguing the clause bars a vote on congressional maps.
STLPR reports Hatfield maintains that clause covers only legislative redistricting done by committee, not congressional maps.
The chief justice's skepticism
The most striking signal came from Chief Justice W. Brent Powell, who STLPR notes cited the court's May ruling that the 2025 map, HB1, would be suspended as of December 9, 2025 if the referendum certificate is sufficient.
Powell appeared unconvinced by the state's warning that suspending a map already used in the August primary could cause electoral chaos, and he told Capozzi the court's review is limited to whether the certificate of insufficiency should be reversed.
Hatfield argued state officials are disregarding that ruling for the November election.
What's at stake
STLPR reports the referendum threatens Republicans' plan to redraw the map to push out Congressman Emanuel Cleaver and gain a Republican seat in the Kansas City area.
Secretary of State Denny Hoskins said he will follow the court's order, but if it does not specify which map to use, he will keep using the 2025 Missouri First map for November.
The legal fights come amid a charged midterm season; Reuters, via KFGO, reports House Democrats on Wednesday defeated a Republican constitutional amendment to cap the Supreme Court at nine justices, a 212-206 messaging vote ahead of the November 3 elections.
What comes next
The court also heard two related referendum cases, including a challenge to Hoskins' rejection of a constitutional amendment that would require an 80% legislative majority to alter voter-approved initiatives, which STLPR says must also be resolved by Tuesday.
The week underscores how active state supreme courts have become: The Colorado Sun reports the Colorado Supreme Court on Monday rejected Xcel Energy's bid to fast-track an eminent domain dispute over a wind-power transmission line.