Kagan Blasts Supreme Court Rulings as a Democracy 'Nightmare'

Justice Elena Kagan warned the Supreme Court's conservative majority has damaged democracy through rulings on gerrymandering and campaign finance.

@sharedot

Kagan Blasts Supreme Court Rulings as a Democracy 'Nightmare'

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Politics
  • Supreme Court
  • Elections

Justice Elena Kagan warned the Supreme Court's conservative majority has damaged democracy through rulings on gerrymandering and campaign finance.

What Kagan Said, Two Weeks Before the Midterms

Supreme Court Justice Elena Kagan sharply criticized her conservative colleagues on Tuesday during a talk at Catholic University's Columbus School of Law in Washington, D.C., two weeks before the pivotal midterm elections for control of Congress.

The liberal justice said the court's recent decisions on voting and campaign finance have damaged the nation's democracy, arguing the majority has "blinded itself to the very deleterious effect of their rulings" and "created a democracy that does not work as well as it should."

Kagan, one of the court's three Democratic appointees, singled out rulings that loosened campaign finance restrictions, sharply limited the Voting Rights Act, and barred federal courts from intervening in partisan gerrymandering — cases in which she dissented.

A 'Race to the Bottom' on Redistricting

Kagan's most pointed criticism targeted the court's 2019 ruling that federal judges cannot throw out congressional maps for being too partisan.

According to Bloomberg Law, she said that decision has produced a "race to the bottom" in redistricting, laying the legal groundwork for this year's unprecedented wave of mid-decade map-drawing as both parties sought to maximize congressional representation in states they control.

She called the gerrymandering phenomenon "very destructive of our democracy" and said it is making an already too-polarized country even more so.

Money in Politics: 'A Nightmare'

The justice also blasted the court's campaign finance rulings, including a June decision that sided with congressional Republicans to abolish limits on how political parties can coordinate directly with candidates.

"The people of America look around this political system and think that all this money chasing all these political candidates is a nightmare," Kagan said. "And they're right."

She argued the rulings had created opportunities for corruption.

Per Bloomberg Law, she tied the spending decisions to public distrust of the political system, while NBC News reports she described the court's consistent strikes against campaign finance restrictions as part of a pattern in which the majority underestimated the consequences of its own rulings on how elections actually function.

The Voting Rights Act and a Redistricting Frenzy

Kagan blamed the court's April 29 Voting Rights Act decision for undercutting racial equality at the ballot box.

According to Bloomberg Law, the ruling limited the use of the landmark 1965 law as a justification for drawing majority-Black or majority-Hispanic districts, and "a large number of Southern states decided to redistrict in order to get rid of Black districts" within weeks of the announcement.

The Washington Post reports she said her colleagues had failed to grasp how damaging the decision would be.

NBC News notes the decision fed a redistricting frenzy touched off by President Donald Trump, with Texas kicking things off at his urging, followed by other states including California, as Republicans try to hold their slim House majority.

Beyond Elections: Originalism and Presidential Power

The remarks went beyond elections.

The Daily Beast reports Kagan criticized her conservative colleagues' embrace of originalism, the theory that the Constitution should be interpreted by the original public meaning of its text, saying the framers "were writing the Constitution for the ages" and that support for originalism is "kind of misconceived."

She also faulted this year's ruling giving Trump greater control over independent federal agencies, warning of "one president being able to ride roughshod over all the other institutions of government."

Yet she pushed back on claims that the 6-3 conservative court is a rubber stamp for Trump, citing rulings against him on tariffs, birthright citizenship, and mail ballots, and said the court has been getting a "bum rap."

What Comes Next

Beyond the election, the court has major cases pending, including whether people can be banned from owning AR-15 rifles and similar semi-automatic weapons, according to The Daily Beast. On November 3, the justices will also hear argument in St. Mary Catholic Parish v.

Roy, a major religious-liberty case that could reshape the court's free exercise doctrine. For Kagan, who has dissented from the key election rulings, the warning was unambiguous: a court majority that stops weighing consequences risks producing a democracy that no longer works.

Sources

  1. washingtonpost.com › Justice Kagan says Supreme Court has damaged democracy with recent rulings
  2. news.bloomberglaw.com › Supreme Court's Kagan Says Election Rulings Creating 'Nightmare'
  3. thedailybeast.com › Supreme Court Justice Tears Into Colleagues in Blistering Takedown
  4. nbcnews.com › Justice Elena Kagan accuses Supreme Court's conservative majority of undermining democracy
  5. bozemandailychronicle.com › Justice Kagan warns Supreme Court rulings are fueling polarization and undermining democracy
  6. scotusblog.com › The Supreme Court's next major case on the free exercise of religion

More on Politics