Blanche Contradicts DOJ Suit in Alaska Certification Fight

AG Todd Blanche insists the DOJ's Alaska Senate lawsuit does not seek to block certification, though the complaint requests exactly that.

@sharedot

Blanche Contradicts DOJ Suit in Alaska Certification Fight

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Politics
  • Alaska Senate Race
  • Election Certification
  • Doj
  • Mary Peltola

AG Todd Blanche insists the DOJ's Alaska Senate lawsuit does not seek to block certification, though the complaint requests exactly that.

Blanche denies what the complaint asks for

Attorney General Todd Blanche claimed Saturday that the Justice Department does not seek to stop Alaska from certifying its Senate election, writing that the litigation only seeks to ensure ballots are preserved so state officials can assess voter confusion.

Democracy Docket reports that his own department's complaint flatly contradicts him, explicitly asking the court to block the state 'from certifying any result that may be impacted by voter confusion.'

According to Democracy Docket, the filing says nothing about requiring officials to preserve ballots, and the only substantive relief requested is a halt to certification pending an investigation.

The suit's actual language

The complaint, filed late Thursday in federal court in Alaska, argues that if Senator Dan Sullivan loses and Daniel J. Sullivan remains on the ballot, the state would 'fail in its obligation to protect the integrity of its election.'

The suit asks the court to declare that certifying such a result would violate the National Voter Registration Act and to block certification pending an investigation into whether votes cast for Daniel J. Sullivan were meant for the incumbent.

Democracy Docket notes the investigation would effectively entail assigning all of Daniel J. Sullivan's votes to Senator Sullivan.

Peltola calls it desperation

Democratic nominee Mary Peltola rebuked the lawsuit on MS NOW, calling it a 'desperate attempt on Dan Sullivan's behalf' and 'exactly the kind of corruption that Alaskans are sick and tired of.'

Yahoo News reports she added that 'this is just a desperate attempt to silence Alaskans,' and argued Alaskans take umbrage at outside meddling from the lower 48. Peltola said she is hopeful a wide enough margin will render the challenge moot, citing heavy participation on the ground.

Trump says he personally ordered it

President Trump told reporters Friday, as he landed for a Florida campaign rally, 'I'm the one that said do it,' taking personal credit for ordering the Justice Department action.

Scripps News reports he has repeatedly attacked the second Sullivan's candidacy on social media, calling it 'CHEATING' and vowing to pursue 'powerful legal options.'

CNN's Kaitlan Collins, cited by AOL, said the president has been 'personally obsessed' with the two-Sullivan saga and made it a staple rally talking point.

Legal experts see no path

Notre Dame law professor Derek Muller, quoted by Scripps News, said the statute 'simply doesn't let the Department of Justice enjoin certification' and predicted the suit would likely be dismissed next month unless mooted by the result.

HuffPost contributor coverage cited by Yahoo News records Muller calling the government's arguments 'absurdly thin' and among the worst he has seen.

PBS News reports experts doubt the preamble phrase 'protect the integrity' can justify overturning an election that under the Constitution is a state affair.

Stakes and what comes next

The race could decide Senate control, with Peltola and Sullivan expected to finish within a few thousand votes in a state of 738,000 people, and Alaska's ranked-choice count likely to take weeks.

PBS notes the suit cites a second Sullivan who drew only about 2% of the August primary vote, and that the state's top court already rejected removing him from the ballot.

Democracy Docket suggests Blanche's reframing indicates the DOJ sees a need to fight off the perception it aims to subvert a GOP loss, and a certification fight would follow only if the incumbent narrowly loses on November 3.

Sources

  1. democracydocket.com › Todd Blanche falsely claims DOJ isn't seeking to block Alaska from certifying Senate contest
  2. scrippsnews.com › Trump says he ordered the Justice Department's lawsuit over Alaska's US Senate race
  3. sg.news.yahoo.com › Alaska Senate Candidate Brands Trump's Attempt To Halt Election Certification 'Desperate'
  4. aol.com › CNN's Kaitlan Collins Says Trump Is 'Personally Obsessed' With Dan Sullivan vs. Dan Sullivan Race - AOL
  5. pbs.org › What's going on with Dan Sullivan and Dan Sullivan? The Alaska Senate litigation, explained

More on Politics