Map Opponents Ask Supreme Court to Stay Missouri Order

People Not Politicians urgently asked the justices to block a federal order forcing Missouri to use its GOP-drawn congressional map, with responses due Thursday.

@sharedot

Map Opponents Ask Supreme Court to Stay Missouri Order

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Politics
  • Missouri Redistricting
  • Supreme Court

People Not Politicians urgently asked the justices to block a federal order forcing Missouri to use its GOP-drawn congressional map, with responses due Thursday.

What happened

Just one day after Justice Brett Kavanaugh left in place a Missouri Supreme Court ruling barring the new congressional map, opponents returned to the U.S. Supreme Court.

In a 25-page filing on Wednesday afternoon, Richard von Glahn and the group People Not Politicians asked the justices to stay a temporary restraining order by Chief U.S. District Judge Stephen Clark that would require the state to use the new Republican-drawn map in the November elections.

SCOTUSblog reports that Abha Khanna told the justices the order had 'been in place for mere hours, but the chaos it guarantees has already taken root.'

Why it is surprising

The filing came after a dizzying sequence of conflicting commands within a single day. Kavanaugh turned down the state's emergency request without referring it to the full court, and less than an hour later Judge Clark issued his order directing Missouri to use the 2025 map.

PBS reports that the dueling court orders, arriving eight weeks before Election Day, left voters in parts of the state uncertain which district they will be in.

CBS News notes that the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 8th Circuit also rejected a request to stay Clark's ruling, citing doubts about either jurisdiction or the stay factors.

The evidence

According to SCOTUSblog, the map's opponents told the justices that Clark's order requires Missouri to conduct its congressional election using a map that, under the Missouri Supreme Court's authoritative decision, 'is not the law and has never been the law.'

They argued a stay would harm neither the plaintiffs nor the public, and that leaving the order in force would cause the very confusion and disruption the Purcell principle forbids.

They also noted officials confirmed the old map is feasible, since Secretary of State Denny Hoskins himself instructed administrators to implement the 2022 map after the state court ruling.

The stakes

House seats by dismantling Democratic Rep. Emanuel Cleaver's Kansas City-area district. PBS reports that about 59% of that district's voters would be new under the revised map.

CBS News reports Republicans had hoped new House maps in eight states could add as many as 16 seats, while Democrats count on up to six new seats from California and Utah, making Missouri's map a meaningful piece of the battle for the House majority.

What comes next

Kavanaugh has instructed Rep. Robert Onder and Hoskins to respond by 10 a.m. EDT Thursday, so a decision on the stay could come quickly.

In a related proceeding, the Missouri Supreme Court has scheduled contempt arguments for Thursday at 10 a.m. over Hoskins' Sept. 8 email instructing officials to use the 2025 map, and KCTV reports Attorney General Catherine Hanaway filed an emergency federal motion Wednesday asking Judge Clark to halt that contempt proceeding, arguing the Supremacy Clause and the 'impossibility doctrine' place Hoskins in a legal trap between conflicting mandates.

Why it matters

Federal law sets a Sept. 19 deadline to begin mailing absentee ballots to overseas citizens and military members, and Missouri's deadline to change November ballot candidates has already passed, according to PBS.

Whichever map prevails will determine which districts Missouri voters cast ballots in — including whether Cleaver's old district or State Sen. Rick Brattin's reshaped primary seat is used — and the resolution will test how courts untangle directly conflicting state and federal orders on the eve of a federal election.

Sources

  1. scotusblog.com › Missouri congressional redistricting dispute returns to the Supreme Court
  2. cbsnews.com › Federal judge backs Missouri's new House map favoring Republicans hours after Supreme Court declines to hear case
  3. pbs.org › Competing court orders add confusion to Missouri congressional elections
  4. kctv5.com › 'Impossible position': Missouri AG asks federal judge to halt state supreme court showdown

More on Politics