Shane Gillis Says He Promised SNL 'No Controversy'

Shane Gillis tells Joe Rogan he graded his 'SNL' monologue a C minus and promised the show 'no controversy' before the backlash hit.

@sharedot

Shane Gillis Says He Promised SNL 'No Controversy'

By @sharedot · · 7 pages

  • Comedy
  • Shane Gillis
  • Saturday Night Live
  • Stand Up
  • Joe Rogan

Shane Gillis tells Joe Rogan he graded his 'SNL' monologue a C minus and promised the show 'no controversy' before the backlash hit.

What Happened: Gillis Breaks His Silence on Rogan's Podcast

On the November 13 episode of the *Joe Rogan Experience*, Shane Gillis finally addressed the fallout from his October 10 *Saturday Night Live* hosting monologue, during his third time hosting the show.

According to The Hollywood Reporter, Gillis said *SNL* did not give him feedback on the material beforehand and explained that the show doesn't approve comedians' sets: "They could shut it down. They could, but you don't write your set and give them."

He told the show he had promised "there's no controversy" and that the set was just him "calling myself fat for 10 minutes." USA Today notes the comedian also said he doesn't have a problem with how women dress at the gym, and that the backlash "obviously had a lot to do with the climate."

The C Minus Heard Around Comedy

The funniest — and most quoted — detail of Gillis's defense is his self-grading.

Per Rolling Stone Australia, he told Rogan: "The whole time, I was like, 'Fellas, I'm giving you a solid C minus of a monologue, but I promise there's no controversy. I'm calling myself fat for fucking 10 minutes. That's it.'"

Rolling Stone adds that most non-comedians have their monologues written by the *SNL* staff, with Taylor Swift's 2009 monologue song the famous exception.

The Philadelphia Inquirer reports Gillis also caught heat for an uncensored f-bomb during a Dr. Seuss-themed "Green Eggs and Ham" sketch, for which he apologized.

Watch: The Rogan Interview Driving the Story

Watch on YouTube · PowerfulJRE · 3:41:28

  1. — No roads. It's all smugglers and
  2. — You have to show your ID to buy creatine
  3. — We got to eat at Peter

The interview itself is the news event here: Gillis chose Rogan's podcast, not a press release, to answer critics a month after the monologue aired.

That choice matters to comedy fans because it mirrors the argument at the heart of the dust-up — Gillis framed the reaction as being about "the climate" rather than the joke, while his critics framed it as misogyny on live national television.

USA Today reports the show has reached out to an *SNL* representative for comment, and that Gillis told Rogan the network could have shut the set down but doesn't review it beforehand.

The Evidence: Who Slammed It and Who Defended It

The criticism came from inside comedy's own house. USA Today details former *SNL* cast members Ego Nwodim and Cecily Strong among the critics, with Dan Levy posting that "Women wearing short shorts to the gym does not make them whores. It makes the men calling them whores misogynists."

Inde Navarrette, who hosted the Halloween episode, needled the joke from the same stage: "Every morning, I put on my little whore outfit, and I hit the gym." Rolling Stone Australia reports Maren Morris posted herself "being a wh0re at the gym" set to her song "Be a Bitch."

The Inquirer notes feminist author Jessica Valenti asked "What do you think rape culture is?" — while David Spade, Dana Carvey and Jimmy Carr came to Gillis's defense, per The Hollywood Reporter, and Kathy Griffin told Page Six she defended his right to say it "and everyone else's right to think less of him."

The Stakes: From Fired Castmember to World-Record Headliner

The history here is what makes the reversal so striking: as outlets across the pack note, Gillis was announced as an *SNL* cast member in 2019 and fired before ever appearing, after past podcast comments resurfaced — yet he has now hosted three times.

The Inquirer reports that in July his one-night-only special at Lincoln Financial Field broke Guinness World Records for attendance and tickets sold.

Sources

  1. hollywoodreporter.com › Shane Gillis Addresses 'SNL' Monologue Backlash, Says He Promised the Show There Would Be "No Controversy"
  2. usatoday.com › Shane Gillis says backlash over 'SNL' monologue 'had a lot to do with the climate'
  3. au.rollingstone.com › Shane Gillis Grades His Own Mediocre 'SNL' Monologue a C Minus
  4. inquirer.com › Comedian Shane Gillis responds to backlash over 'Saturday Night Live' monologue

More on Comedy