Secret WH Bunker Undercuts Trump Ballroom Case
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Politics
- Supreme Court
- White House
- Trump Administration
- National Security
Insiders reveal an existing Obama-era bunker beneath the White House, undermining Trump's national.
What Happened
White House insiders revealed to The Washington Post — as reported by The Daily Beast — that a highly protected nuclear bunker already exists deep beneath the White House, secretly completed during the Obama administration.
According to The Daily Beast, three former officials said the facility is buried more than 60 feet beneath the White House complex and can shelter the president and top aides for multiple weeks.
The existence of this modern bunker undermines the Trump administration's legal argument that its new ballroom project — which includes an underground bunker — is a national security necessity.
Why It Is Surprising
The disclosure is surprising because the Trump administration has aggressively framed the ballroom as a critical security installation. According to The Daily Beast, Trump has described the project as a 'military complex' with a 'drone port' and 'bomb shelter.'
Solicitor General John Sauer argued in court filings that every day without the project's security features presents 'unacceptable risk,' The Daily Beast reported.
Yet Yahoo News notes that the Obama-era facility was designed to withstand a nuclear blast and allow the president to run the country from a secure command center.
The Evidence
Time Magazine reports that two lower courts found the National Trust for Historic Preservation likely to succeed on its claim that the aboveground ballroom requires congressional approval. The D.C.
Circuit panel upheld the injunction, stating each president is a 'temporary tenant, not the owner' of the White House, according to Time. The Daily Beast reports that the project's cost has ballooned from an estimated $200 million to $600 million, with taxpayers expected to cover more than half.
The administration claims the project is 65% complete, according to Time. The National Trust has accused the administration of 'trying to outrun judicial review,' as the material used makes the structure 'virtually impossible to deconstruct,' The Daily Beast reported.
The Stakes
The legal battle centers on whether a president can unilaterally make major, permanent changes to federally owned property without congressional authorization. The National Trust argues the Property Clause of the Constitution requires congressional approval, as Time Magazine reported.
According to The Daily Beast, the administration has shifted from treating the aboveground ballroom and underground bunker as separate components to describing them as inseparable — a distinction that could determine the outcome.
University of Baltimore law professor Kimberly Wehle told Time that Roberts's stay gives Trump 'exactly what he wants' by allowing construction to proceed.
Wehle questioned whether the President is being accommodated because the project has gone too far to undo, asking, 'What kind of precedent does that set?'
What Comes Next
According to Time Magazine, there is no established timeline for when the Supreme Court might take further action on the emergency application. The case raises the question of whether a majority of the structure could be completed before litigation is resolved, as Time notes.
If the project is ultimately found unlawful after substantial completion, courts could face unusual questions about available remedies — including whether a structure could be ordered altered, reverted, or removed, Time reported.
The revelation of the existing bunker may further complicate the administration's national security argument.
Broader Context
The ballroom controversy unfolds amid a period of intense Supreme Court activity on multiple fronts.
Ohio House Democrats condemned a Supreme Court ruling striking down Louisiana's second majority-Black congressional district, with Minority Leader Dani Isaacsohn calling it a 'devastating blow to voting rights,' according to the Ohio House of Representatives.
The ACLU of Texas reported that more than two dozen families are urging the Supreme Court to block a state law requiring Ten Commandments displays in public school classrooms. The Cavalier Daily reported that the Court upheld birthright citizenship in a 6-3 decision in June.
Sources
- thedailybeast.com › Insiders Blow Up Trump's New Ballroom Excuse
- time.com › The Supreme Court Let Trump's Ballroom Proceed—for Now. Here's What That Means
- sg.news.yahoo.com › Existing WH Bunker Weakens Trump's National Security Argument For His Ballroom: WaPo
- ohiohouse.gov › Leader Isaacsohn and Asst. Minority Whip Desiree Tims Condemns Supreme Court Ruling Weakening the Voting Rights Act
- aclutx.org › Texas Families Urge U.S. Supreme Court To Hear Challenge to Law Requiring Ten Commandments in Public School Classrooms
- cavalierdaily.com › After Supreme Court upholds birthright citizenship, students express relief and disappointment