Supreme Court Again Rejects Trump Bid to Overturn Carroll Verdict
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Politics
- Supreme Court
- Trump
- E Jean Carroll
- Presidential Immunity
The Supreme Court denied Trump's rehearing request, leaving the $5 million Carroll verdict intact.
Court Denies Rehearing Request
On Monday, August 17, 2026, the Supreme Court turned down President Donald Trump's request to reconsider its refusal to hear the Carroll suit against him. The court did not provide any explanation for its decision to deny Trump's petition for rehearing, consistent with its general practice.
According to SCOTUSblog, the announcement came as part of the second of three scheduled summer order lists, which normally serve as an opportunity for the justices to clear out pending requests for action that accrue during their summer recess.
According to The Guardian, the decision was unsigned and listed Trump's petition under "rehearings denied."
A Rarely Granted Remedy
Trump's request faced steep odds from the outset. According to SCOTUSblog, the Supreme Court has not granted a petition for rehearing since 2018, making such filings long-shot endeavors by their very nature.
According to SCOTUSblog, Trump returned to the court on July 8, 2026, asking the justices to reconsider their denial of his original petition for review, which he had filed in November 2025.
SCOTUSblog reports that the court denied the original petition four days after its June 25, 2026 conference; CNBC similarly described the denial as occurring in late June.
According to SCOTUSblog, the court had initially slated consideration of his original petition for a February 20, 2026 conference before postponing it. CNBC reports that Trump asked the court to reconsider in early July.
The Verdict and the Payment
A civil jury in 2023 found Trump liable for sexually abusing Carroll and defaming her. The $5 million verdict against Trump in the Carroll suit remains intact following the court's decision.
According to SCOTUSblog, Carroll alleged Trump sexually assaulted her in 1996 in a dressing room at a New York department store, and she filed the lawsuit in 2022. Carroll was paid more than $5.6 million.
According to CNBC, the payment comprised the damages award plus post-judgment interest. SCOTUSblog reports that Carroll received the $5 million plus interest on July 13, 2026.
The Guardian notes that Trump had deposited the award plus interest into a court-held account several weeks after the verdict, and that in July 2026 a Manhattan federal judge ordered the funds be released to Carroll.
Verdict Is Now Final
Carroll's attorney Roberta Kaplan stated the verdict is now final and cannot be challenged in any court. "We are pleased that the United States Supreme Court has declined again to hear this case," Kaplan said in a statement reported by CNBC.
She emphasized that the jury's unanimous verdict that Donald Trump sexually assaulted and then defamed E. Jean Carroll is now final. The Supreme Court's decision leaves Trump no remaining options to challenge the verdict.
According to CNBC, Trump's legal team responded by stating the American People stand with President Trump and demand an end to all Witch Hunts.
Trump's Legal Arguments
According to SCOTUSblog, Trump argued Carroll should not have been allowed to introduce testimony by other women who also alleged that Trump had assaulted them, as well as the 2005 Access Hollywood tape in which Trump bragged about grabbing women by their genitals.
Carroll urged the justices to turn down Trump's appeal, arguing that even if the introduction of the evidence was improper, it ultimately did not matter because the rest of her case was so strong.
In his rehearing request, Trump contended that Carroll's lawyers had relied on statements he made while president. Trump's legal team argued that presidential immunity shields him from Carroll's claims, and that those statements constitute protected official acts.
According to SCOTUSblog, if the Supreme Court agrees, the statements should not have been introduced into evidence in the 2022 case.
The Separate $83.3 Million Case Looms
A separate federal jury ordered Trump to pay Carroll $83.3 million in damages for defaming her in 2019.
According to SCOTUSblog, Trump's legal team filed a second petition for review on July 28, 2026 in the $83.3 million Carroll lawsuit, and the Supreme Court is likely to consider that petition in the fall.
The Guardian reports that a federal appeals court upheld the $83.3 million jury award last September. Trump's lawyers argue presidential immunity shields him from Carroll's claims in that case.
According to NewsCord, Trump's lawyers also argue that lower courts wrongly decided he had forfeited that defense. The Guardian also reported that the White House did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the Supreme Court's decision.