Clancy Judge Eyes March 2027 Retrial in Fiery Hearing
By @sharedot · · 7 pages
- True Crime
- Lindsay Clancy
- Retrial
- Court Hearing
A heated Plymouth hearing saw Judge William Sullivan float a March 2027 retrial as lawyers clashed over the holdout juror and a gag order.
What Happened in Plymouth Court
The hearing focused on the defense's motion to dismiss the three murder charges on double jeopardy grounds.
Judge William Sullivan did not immediately rule, and instead scheduled a Nov. 16 hearing to revisit the case and potentially set a retrial date, saying he would take the arguments under advisement and issue rulings in the coming weeks, per CNN reporting carried by RNZ.
Scripps News reports that proceedings grew heated as attorneys squared off before the judge.
The Judge's Surprise Retrial Timeline
The most striking development: Sullivan said Monday he would like to schedule any retrial for March 2027, RNZ reports.
Prosecutors stayed non-committal — prosecutor Jennifer Sprague said a retrial 'will depend' on the judge's rulings on pending motions, and Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy Cruz told reporters outside court, 'I'll be talking more on November 16.'
That prompted defense attorney Kevin Reddington to accuse prosecutors of 'spinning everyone in the breeze' and demand speed: 'I will not have this woman sit in jail for another year or two or three. I want a trial, and I want it with you, and I want it this spring.'
A possible plea deal that could end the case outright also remains a remote possibility, per RNZ.
Fireworks Over the Holdout Juror
The hearing exploded when Reddington demanded the holdout juror's phone records and questionnaire, publicly identifying juror Michael Desronvil and alleging he used a cellphone to research the case and was dishonest on his jury questionnaire, Scripps News and RNZ both report.
Sullivan repeatedly interrupted, urging 'Why don't we all dial this back a little bit,' and told Reddington to use a pseudonym.
Attorney Heather O'Connor, representing Desronvil, said jurors were allowed to keep phones and the account cited showed scrolling, not research: 'We are here because Juror Doe did not vote the way that the defense needed,' she said, warning that rewarding such challenges would teach future jurors to 'agree with the majority or potentially be investigated.'
The Evidence Behind the Double Jeopardy Fight
Defense attorney Martin G. Weinberg argued Sullivan should have investigated further after the jury foreperson sent two notes saying a juror was not following the rules, contending a single question to all 12 jurors was 'constitutionally insufficient' and that deeper questioning could have removed the holdout and avoided the mistrial.
Sullivan pushed back: 'Didn't I do that? Didn't I do a voir dire?'
Sprague countered that the judge struck the right balance, and RNZ quotes her telling the court: 'It was clear from the record this juror did not refuse to deliberate. He refused to agree.'
Prosecutors argue double jeopardy 'does not bar the Commonwealth from seeking justice on behalf of the three victims,' per Scripps News.
Gag Order Request and What Comes Next
Prosecutors also asked Sullivan to impose a gag order restricting public statements by attorneys and their supporters, arguing Reddington's remarks about the holdout juror, a pardon appeal to President Trump and his media interviews were 'calculated to affect public perception of this case.'
The defense opposes the order as an unconstitutional prior restraint, per Scripps News.
RNZ notes prosecutors could retry Clancy on first-degree murder, bring lesser charges such as manslaughter, or drop the case entirely; she remains held at Tewksbury Hospital, partially paralyzed from her suicide attempt, and could face life in prison if convicted.