Two Sheriffs Indicted for Obstruction in Kouri Richins Case

A Utah grand jury indicted sheriffs Jared Rigby and Dave Edmunds on obstruction charges in the Kouri Richins murder case.

@sharedot

Two Sheriffs Indicted for Obstruction in Kouri Richins Case

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • True Crime
  • Kouri Richins
  • Obstruction Of Justice
  • Utah
  • Sheriffs Indicted

A Utah grand jury indicted sheriffs Jared Rigby and Dave Edmunds on obstruction charges in the Kouri Richins murder case.

What Happened

Two Utah law enforcement leaders now face criminal charges themselves.

A grand jury indicted Wasatch County Sheriff Jared Rigby and former Summit County Sheriff Dave Edmunds on felony obstruction-of-justice charges connected to the prosecution of Kouri Richins, who was convicted of fatally poisoning her husband Eric with fentanyl and sentenced to life without parole.

The indictments were filed in Third Judicial District Court and unsealed Wednesday with significant redactions. Rigby was charged with a second-degree felony count of obstruction of justice in a criminal proceeding plus a misdemeanor count of making a written false statement.

Edmunds faces a third-degree felony obstruction charge. Both men have pleaded not guilty.

Why It's Surprising

The twist is who stands accused: the sitting sheriff of Wasatch County and a former Summit County sheriff, charged over alleged interference in a murder prosecution that riveted the nation.

According to defense motions cited by ABC News, Rigby's indictment alleges he made, presented or used a knowingly false item in January 'with intent to hinder' a prosecution, while Edmunds is accused of providing false information in March intended to hinder an investigation.

Rigby had already lost his June primary election, and the lead detective on the Richins case, Eric Mainord, had briefly run against him for the sheriff's job before dropping out in May.

The Anonymous Letter

The obstruction investigation, as reported by The Salt Lake Tribune via KPCW, centered on an anonymous letter postmarked January 10, 2026, that prosecutors in the Richins case received weeks before her February trial. The letter contained allegations related to lead detective Eric Mainord.

A motion from Rigby's attorney indicates the charges accuse Rigby of sending the letter, which allegedly contained false information, and prosecutors say he sought to discredit Mainord with help from Edmunds and other top law enforcement officials.

Edmunds' motion, per ABC News, states his indictment connects the letter to alleged misconduct by a Summit County sheriff's deputy and accuses him of a false statement intended to hinder identification of the letter's author.

The Stakes for Richins' Case

The indictments land while Richins is still fighting her conviction.

According to The Salt Lake Tribune, her attorneys recently asked to pause her motion for a new trial until the obstruction investigation was complete, but Judge Richard Mrazik — who presided over her trial and sentenced her to life without parole — denied the request.

Her new-trial request is now under consideration by the Utah Court of Appeals, per ABC News. This week Mrazik also ordered Richins to pay more than $55 million in damages to her late husband's estate and family, including about $41.3 million in punitive damages.

She was also ordered to pay $3 million in non-economic damages — $1 million for each of her three children.

Redacted Charges, Public Scrutiny

Details of exactly what the two sheriffs allegedly did remain largely hidden. Specific allegations were redacted in the publicly available charging documents, and both outlets note the filings give only fragments of the alleged scheme.

Judge Richard Mrazik has set a hearing for November 4 to consider whether the charging document can be publicly released, according to The Salt Lake Tribune. The judge is the same one who presided over Richins' murder trial, adding another layer of overlap between the two proceedings.

Rigby, who remains sheriff until January despite losing his primary, has previously said he acted lawfully, and ABC News reports the two men's attorneys did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

What Comes Next

The two sheriffs are due in state court with a hearing set for November 4 on the redaction question, and both have pleaded not guilty to the charges.

Rigby will leave office in January after losing the Republican primary to Wasatch County emergency manager Jeremy Hales, meaning the county will have a new sheriff even as the case against him proceeds.

Meanwhile, Kouri Richins' appeal for a new trial continues at the Utah Court of Appeals, keeping the underlying murder case — which gained national attention after she published a children's book about grief following her husband's 2022 death — very much alive in the courts.

Sources

  1. kutv.com › Two sheriffs indicted on obstruction charges related to Kouri Richins murder case
  2. sltrib.com › Grand jury indicts Wasatch County Sheriff, former Summit County sheriff over alleged interference in Kouri Richins' case
  3. abcnews.com › Sheriff, former sheriff charged with obstruction of justice related to Kouri Richins case: Filings

More on True Crime