Roberts Lets Trump White House Ballroom Proceed

Chief Justice Roberts temporarily halted lower court orders blocking Trump's $400M ballroom.

@sharedot

Roberts Lets Trump White House Ballroom Proceed

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Politics
  • Supreme Court
  • Executive Power
  • White House
  • Constitutional Law

Chief Justice Roberts temporarily halted lower court orders blocking Trump's $400M ballroom.

Chief Justice Issues Emergency Stay

Chief Justice John Roberts signed a temporary order on Friday allowing the White House to continue construction on President Donald Trump's $400 million ballroom project, pausing lower-court rulings that would have forced a halt to aboveground construction.

The one-page document does not detail Roberts' reasoning or indicate when another ruling will come. Roberts signed the order because he oversees emergency appeals of cases filed in the capital.

The stay will remain in place until the Supreme Court issues a more durable decision, according to WAKA 8 and KJCT reporting.

Two Courts Had Ruled Against Trump

The order reverses momentum against the project. According to WQOW, two lower courts found Trump is pursuing the ballroom unlawfully because Congress has not approved it.

In April, District Judge Richard Leon ordered a stop to aboveground construction, though he permitted work to continue on a bunker beneath the planned ballroom.

In early August, the DC Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that ruling in a divided decision, with WQOW reporting the court stated: 'Whether or not a massive ballroom should be constructed is for Congress to decide and is not a matter for Executive self-help.'

The appeals court required work to cease starting August 21.

Rapid Construction Outpacing Litigation

The Trump administration says 65% of the work on the planned 90,000-square-foot ballroom has already been completed, with a 250-person crew working 20 hours a day, seven days a week.

Approximately $200 million in private donations has been spent or committed, according to court documents filed by the Justice Department.

WQOW reports that Solicitor General D. John Sauer told justices the building uses a type of concrete also used at nuclear power plants that is nearly impossible to deconstruct. Trump posted on social media that the project is 'under budget and ahead of schedule,' thanking the high court.

Presidential Power vs. Congressional Authority

The administration argues the president has total authority to renovate the White House and other federal buildings as he sees fit and that the ballroom must be completed due to national security concerns.

When Trump first announced the plans, he did not emphasize national security and said the project would be funded by private donations, including from himself.

The National Trust for Historic Preservation argues Trump has no unilateral authority to undertake the work, which included demolishing the East Wing.

WQOW reports that Trump has described the ballroom as 'the greatest military complex slash ballroom anywhere in the world' and said opponents are 'very disloyal to our country.'

Preservation Group Warns of Irreversible Harm

Lawyers for the National Trust for Historic Preservation accused the White House of trying to 'outrun the courts' by accelerating construction. A spokesperson for the trust said Friday that Roberts' order is not a final decision and the group is awaiting further action.

WQOW reports the Trust told justices that a decision favorable to the president would cause 'the type of irreparable harm courts weighing emergency disputes are typically sympathetic to.'

The Trust's lawyers argued that the injunction only stops construction of a ballroom without prior congressional approval and does not prevent continued work on the bunker or site security.

Full Supreme Court to Weigh In Next

Roberts is certain to refer the case to all nine justices, who will likely weigh in on whether construction can continue for the potentially long duration of the lawsuit.

The administration has scored a series of victories on the Supreme Court's emergency docket, though justices have ruled against some of the president's signature policies after fuller review.

WQOW reports that the price tag has steadily increased — the administration initially put the cost at $200 million, Trump later said 'about $300 million,' and this month said '$400 million almost' had already been spent. The full court's timing for a decision remains unclear.

Sources

  1. waka.com › U.S. Supreme Court chief justice allows work on Trump's $400 million White House ballroom to continue for now
  2. kjct8.com › Supreme Court allows White House ballroom construction to continue
  3. wqow.com › Supreme Court temporarily allows construction of White House ballroom to continue
  4. telegraphherald.com › Supreme Court's chief justice allows work on White House ballroom to continue for now

More on Politics