San Gennaro Centenary Reopens Old Wounds Over Little Italy
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Culture
- Festivals
- San Gennaro
- Little Italy
- Italian American History
As the feast turns 100, The Conversation traces its immigrant roots while Mayor Mamdani's omission of Little Italy from an enclave map sparks backlash.
The Feast as an Immigrant Story
Writing in The Conversation, medievalist Clare Whitton argues the story of Little Italy's Feast of San Gennaro is the story of how Italian immigrants became American. 27.
Founded in 1926 by parishioners of the Church of the Most Precious Blood, led by Alexander Tisi, the feast honored San Gennaro, the early Christian bishop beheaded outside Naples on Sept. 19 in AD 305 during the Diocletian Persecutions.
From Suspect Procession to City Institution
The Conversation's account attributes the festival's early troubles to religious and ethnic prejudice. Between 1881 and 1920, over 4.5 million Italians immigrated to America, and Irish Catholics and Protestants dismissed their street processions as pagan.
In 1928, Police Commissioner Joseph Warren banned the procession over the dollar bills tacked to the statue, calling it a 'profanation of sacred religious symbols' — a move reversed by a New York Supreme Court judge on religious-liberty grounds.
By the 1970s, phys.org reports the feast drew some 3 million visitors a year.
A Centenary Shadowed by Controversy
According to The Conversation via phys.org, this year's festival is dedicated to the Italian Americans who contributed to New York's birth, but arrives amid controversy: two months earlier, Mayor Zohran Mamdani omitted Little Italy from a map of the city's immigrant enclaves, sparking immediate backlash.
Mamdani vowed to reinsert the neighborhood, though some argued the omission reflected the dwindling Italian population along Mulberry Street. In 2007, some residents petitioned Mayor Bloomberg to cancel the festival; he declined, saying the event was part of New York itself.
What Opening Night Looked Like
EV Grieve's Stacie Joy photographed an opening night she describes as crowded, loud, raucous and expensive — 'in other words, the Feast of San Gennaro.'
Among the deep-fried experiments she noted were deep-fried rainbow cookies and deep-fried PB&J Uncrustables, alongside the religious procession through the packed streets.
She also spotted Lucy the Sausage Queen, who clarified that her stand is the one in the middle of the festivities, keeping her longtime slogan: 'Lucy's hot, Lucy's sweet, Lucy's sausage can't be beat!'
TV Crews and the Question of Assimilation
Fox News aired a segment on Sept. 20 with Griff Jenkins, Rachel Campos-Duffy and Charlie Hurt visiting Little Italy to celebrate the 100-year tradition, while ABC7's Kemberly Richardson covered the festival's milestone opening on Thursday.
Whitton's argument cuts against the commercial gloss — Sinatra impersonators and Godfather T-shirts — contending that centuries-old Neapolitan rituals coexisting with sausage and pizza slices reveal a long, 'strenuous and beautiful' process of cultural assimilation.
Stakes and What Comes Next
The feast runs through Sept. 27, leaving time for visitors to crowd 11 blocks along Mulberry Street, where ABC7 reports more than 300 vendors are selling pizza, pasta, cannoli and gelato alongside music, games and rides.
The Conversation's central question frames the stakes for the neighborhood's future: how to honor the immigrants who built New York even as their descendants have left the old enclaves.
This year's grand marshal, San Gennaro himself, the outlet suggests, remains a bridge between the children of the Italian diaspora and their forebears.
Sources
- phys.org › The story of Little Italy's Feast of San Gennaro is the story of how Italian immigrants became American
- evgrieve.com › At the opening night of the Feast of San Gennaro
- abc7ny.com › San Gennaro feast marks 100th year in New York City's Little Italy
- foxnews.com › Fox News heads to Little Italy to celebrate 100-year San Gennaro tradition