Trump Orders DOJ Suit to Block Alaska Senate Certification

Trump says he personally directed the DOJ to sue Alaska and block Senate certification if Sen. Dan Sullivan loses to Mary Peltola.

@sharedot

Trump Orders DOJ Suit to Block Alaska Senate Certification

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Politics
  • Alaska Senate
  • Midterm Elections 2026
  • Election Certification

Trump says he personally directed the DOJ to sue Alaska and block Senate certification if Sen. Dan Sullivan loses to Mary Peltola.

What happened: a preemptive challenge to a Senate race

The Justice Department on Thursday filed a federal lawsuit against Alaska election officials asking a judge to block certification of the November 3 U.S. Senate race unless Republican incumbent Sen. Dan Sullivan wins.

On Friday, President Trump told reporters in Florida, "I'm the one that said do it."

The suit argues that another candidate named Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a retired teacher, could confuse voters and siphon votes from the incumbent, and it asks that certification be paused "pending an investigation" if Sullivan loses by a margin smaller than the other Sullivan's vote total.

Why it is unprecedented

Voting rights experts say no administration has ever tried to stop certification of an election before votes are even counted.

David Becker of the Center for Election Innovation & Research called it "an unprecedented intervention by the federal government," noting the name-confusion issue was already fully litigated and that federal law gives DOJ no role in how states certify Senate elections.

The legal case looks thin

The DOJ complaint cites broad integrity language in the preamble of the 1993 National Voter Registration Act, an argument election law scholars dismissed almost immediately. Notre Dame law professor Derek Mueller wrote that the claim is "absurdly thin" with "essentially no likelihood of success."

Florida State's Michael Morley told Votebeat the lawsuit is "frivolous and will be quickly dismissed," while George Mason's Ilya Somin said suppressing candidates over potential confusion would violate the First Amendment.

Alaska's supreme court already ruled in June that Daniel J. Sullivan could stay on the ballot.

Alaska pushes back across party lines

Republican Sen. Lisa Murkowski condemned the suit, writing that Alaskans "don't need any help voting" and that "the Department of Justice should never have filed this lawsuit." Peltola called it "flagrant corruption" at the Alaska Federation of Natives convention.

The ballot itself distinguishes the candidates: the senator appears as "registered Republican" and "incumbent," while Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. is listed with no party affiliation.

Alaska Public Media reports that both Democratic and some Republican state legislators doubt voters could confuse the two, and Sullivan's campaign said Alaskans "are smart enough to figure out the difference."

The stakes: Senate control and a precedent

Alaska could decide which party controls the Senate, and polls show a dead heat between Sullivan and Peltola, who would be the first Democrat to hold the seat in nearly two decades. Trump has separately attacked Alaska's ranked-choice voting as a "scam" and backs a ballot measure to repeal it.

Even if the suit fails, Votebeat notes the Senate itself could contest the results, as it did in disputed New Hampshire and Iowa races in 1975 and 1924. Democrats see the filing as part of a broader DOJ push to inject federal control into state-run elections.

What comes next

The case has been assigned to U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason, an Obama appointee, according to Democracy Docket, and early voting is already underway with more than 30,000 Alaskans having cast ballots as of Friday.

Legal observers expect motions to dismiss, and experts note a post-election investigation into voters' intent would be practically impossible under the secret ballot.

Sources

  1. theguardian.com › Trump says he ordered DoJ to file lawsuit to block Alaska Senate results certification
  2. abcnews.com › Trump told DOJ to sue to block Alaska Senate results if Republican narrowly loses
  3. bbc.com › Trump administration sues to block certification of Alaska election
  4. votebeat.org › Trump orders lawsuit to block U.S. Senate results in Alaska if Republican incumbent loses
  5. alaskapublic.org › Alaskans, legal experts condemn federal lawsuit as attempt to invalidate the vote
  6. nbcnews.com › Trump administration sues to block Alaska Senate certification if Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan loses
  7. democracydocket.com › Trump on DOJ challenge to Alaska election: 'I'm the one that said do it'

More on Politics