Supreme Court Urged to Leave Missouri GOP Map Blocked
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Politics
- Missouri
- Redistricting
- Supreme Court
- Gerrymandering
A Missouri organizer asked the Supreme Court to leave in place a state ruling barring a Republican congressional map expected to add a GOP seat.
What Happened
On Monday, Missouri organizer Richard von Glahn urged the U.S. Supreme Court to leave in place a unanimous Missouri Supreme Court ruling that bars the state from using a new congressional map expected to give Republicans seven of eight U.S. House seats.
The state's highest court ruled Sept. 3 that a referendum petition with more than 300,000 signatures was "legal, sufficient, and timely," meaning the 2025 map, known as HB 1, "never took effect" and cannot be used unless approved by voters in November 2026.
Why It Matters for GOP Gains
The map fight stems from President Trump's call for Republican-led states to redraw districts outside the normal decennial cycle. Emanuel Cleaver much harder to win, while the 2022 map in force now keeps it safe for him.
St. Louis Public Radio reports the ruling could complicate GOP efforts to dismantle the St. Louis-based 1st District, because any future redraw could now also face a voter referendum.
The Emergency Appeal
Secretary of State Denny Hoskins went to the Supreme Court Friday night, arguing the state ruling violates the Constitution's elections clause by letting roughly 3.3% of voters suspend a congressional map by referendum.
KCTV reports that Republican attorneys general from Texas, Florida, and 18 other states filed a brief backing the emergency appeal, while Justice Brett Kavanaugh, who handles Missouri's circuit, ordered a response by Monday at 11 a.m.
The Opposition's Argument
Von Glahn told the justices the case "does not present a real emergency" and argued the Court lacks power to review it because the Missouri Supreme Court rested solely on state law under the adequate and independent state-law doctrine.
According to SCOTUSblog, he also said a stay would provide no relief since HB 1 never took effect and the 2022 plan is the legal status quo, and that Hoskins lacks standing.
Timing Pressure and Accusations
The dispute is racing against a Sept. 8 deadline to make ballot alterations and a Sept. 19 federal deadline for mailing absentee ballots to military and overseas voters.
KCTV reports that People Not Politicians accused Hoskins of deliberately delaying his Aug. 4 rejection of the petition until primary day to "run out the clock."
According to St. Louis Public Radio, both Republican and Democratic election officials dispute the state's claim that it cannot switch back to the 2022 map in time for November.
What Comes Next
Justice Kavanaugh's decision on the stay is critical, since it determines whether the 2022 or 2025 map governs November's election.
According to St. Louis Public Radio, the attorney general's office made a notable concession, no longer contesting the referendum itself and asking only that the 2025 map be used while voters decide its fate.
Republicans Bob Onder and Rick Brattin also filed a separate federal lawsuit seeking to restore the map, which People Not Politicians calls a "collusive lawsuit," leaving multiple legal tracks open as Election Day approaches.
Sources
- scotusblog.com › Missouri organizer urges Supreme Court to leave ruling in place preventing use of congressional map expected to benefit Republicans
- stlpr.org › Missouri Supreme Court ruling could complicate GOP efforts to redraw St. Louis' 1st District
- kctv5.com › Redistricting battle escalates as 20 states back Missouri's U.S. Supreme Court appeal
- democracydocket.com › Gerrymander foes urge Supreme Court not to revive GOP map in Missouri