Judge Blocks Trump Mail Ballot Rule for 14 Days
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Politics
- Mail In Voting
- Elections
- Judiciary
A federal judge in Massachusetts temporarily blocked the Postal Service's mail ballot rule for 14 days as state election officials warn of midterm chaos.
What happened
According to NOTUS, U.S. District Judge Indira Talwani in Massachusetts temporarily blocked President Trump's mail-voting executive order late Thursday for 14 days, a decision the Trump administration has appealed.
The order comes as officials in nearly half the states warn in court filings that the U.S. Postal Service's new mail ballot rule would disrupt their November midterm plans.
The rule requires states to submit voter lists, redesign ballot envelopes with USPS approval, and add new Intelligent Mail barcodes.
The Santa Barbara Independent reports California and allied Democratic states filed a separate federal lawsuit in Massachusetts this week arguing the changes are unconstitutional.
Why it is surprising
The injunction landed just days after the Supreme Court handed Trump a procedural win, ruling California had sued too early because no formal rules yet existed, per The Santa Barbara Independent.
Once USPS issued its final rules late last week, states could sue on concrete grounds, and within days a judge found the danger serious enough to halt implementation.
California Attorney General Rob Bonta called the Postal Service rules a "clear violation of the Constitution," which designates states as the primary authority over elections.
The evidence from election officials
Declarations filed in the lawsuit describe concrete operational risks. Vermont Secretary of State Sarah Hanzas said her office had not yet seen or been trained on the new USPS system with less than a week before she must give her mailing list to a print vendor.
North Carolina, set to begin mailing ballots Friday, may be unable to mail ballots at all if the untested system fails, according to a state official's filing.
Hawaii's chief election officer said the rule would force discarding already printed envelopes costing over $79,000, and they may not be deliverable to Hawaii on short notice.
The stakes for voters
NOTUS reports that nearly one-third of Americans voted by mail in the 2024 presidential election, and officials say the changes could disenfranchise voters at alarming scale.
New Mexico's election director warned that any point-in-time eligible list will not match the state's dynamic voter rolls, causing confusion. Nevada's deputy secretary of state argued the rule's data sharing with law enforcement could itself suppress participation.
California officials said enrolling all 23 million voters with USPS would be a massive undertaking; 89% of voters in the state's June primary voted by mail.
Related court fight in South Carolina
In a separate development, a three-judge panel of the Fourth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled on Aug. 18 that South Carolina's rule letting voters 65 and older cast absentee ballots without restrictions violates the 26th Amendment, while younger voters must meet eligibility categories.
Chief Judge Roger Gregory wrote that the state allocates voting opportunities unequally based solely on age, sending the case back to a district court to fix the law. State officials plan to appeal, and the state's election commission said absentee voting rules have not changed.
What comes next
South Carolina can still seek review by the full Fourth Circuit or the Supreme Court, where a split exists: a 2022 Fifth Circuit decision found a similar Texas law constitutional. Both courts' reasoning turns on how each read the 26th Amendment's guarantee against age-based voting limits.
Sources
- independent.com › California Sues to Block Trump's Mail-In Voting Rules Just Days After Loss at Supreme Court
- notus.org › Election Officials Brace for Chaos Over Trump's Mail-in Ballot Rule
- foxnews.com › South Carolina mail-in voting law illegally discriminates, appeals court rules
- postandcourier.com › SC's mail-in voting law for seniors discriminates against the young, US Appeals Court rules