Both Blocks on Trump Mail-Vote Order Lifted

Both blocks on Trump's mail-voting order lifted; new lawsuits filed as no court ruled on legality.

@sharedot

Both Blocks on Trump Mail-Vote Order Lifted

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Politics
  • Elections
  • Supreme Court
  • Mail Voting
  • Voting Rights

Both blocks on Trump's mail-voting order lifted; new lawsuits filed as no court ruled on legality.

Two Injunctions Lifted in 48 Hours

The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday lifted a nationwide injunction blocking President Donald Trump's executive order restricting mail voting.

On Wednesday, U.S. District Judge Indira Talwani in Boston vacated a second injunction she had issued in a separate case brought by voting-rights groups including the League of Women Voters.

Neither ruling addressed the legality of Trump's order; both turned on whether challengers had sued before the policy was finalized. With both injunctions now gone, no court order currently prevents the U.S. Postal Service from applying its new rule to the November election.

No Merits Ruling, Only Procedural Timing

The Supreme Court's unsigned majority opinion said the states' challenges were not ripe for judicial review because the Postal Service had not yet finalized its rule. The court stressed that its decision did not establish that Trump's order or its implementing policies were legal.

According to NBC News, the court was divided 6-3, with the three liberal justices dissenting. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson wrote that the order "needlessly injects chaos and uncertainty into the upcoming midterm elections."

The Nation reports that the ruling was issued through the shadow docket as an emergency decision, with the Republican supermajority giving Trump permission to proceed.

What the USPS Rule Requires

CNBC reports that the Postal Service has now finalized a 95-page rule requiring states to submit each mail voter's name and address to a new USPS portal, along with unique Intelligent Mail barcodes assigned to outgoing and return ballot envelopes.

Election officials would also have to submit envelope designs to USPS for review, and postal employees would scan envelopes before accepting them, returning any that fail verification. According to CNBC, about 30% of voters cast ballots by mail in 2024.

PBS reports that Illinois and two dozen other Democratic-led states are now suing the USPS directly over these requirements, arguing the federal government is intruding on state authority.

States and Local Officials Respond

Colorado Secretary of State Jena Griswold told The Colorado Sun that "at this point, nothing has changed" for Colorado voters, citing remaining litigation and a separate court order still in place.

According to The Colorado Sun, Colorado Attorney General Phil Weiser joined dozens of states in suing again on Wednesday to block the order.

PBS reports that Illinois Attorney General Kwame Raoul stated the Constitution "plainly gives states, not the executive branch, the power to administer elections."

Wisconsin Attorney General Josh Kaul told WPR he remains "very confident" the executive order will not ultimately affect absentee voting in Wisconsin for the upcoming election.

The Clock Is Ticking Toward November

The November midterm election is less than 10 weeks away, and election officials across the country are already preparing to mail ballots to military and overseas voters. According to CNBC, California Governor Gavin Newsom posted that Trump "does not run elections. States do."

CNBC also reports that the White House called the Supreme Court's ruling "a major win for the security of American elections."

WPR reports that Dane County Clerk Scott McDonell said the lack of clarity has left him unsure what to tell voters, with ballots being designed and deadlines for mailing them approaching rapidly.

Fresh Injunctions Could Come Within Days

According to NBC News, Judge Talwani asked the federal government to respond to the voting-rights groups' new injunction request by noon Thursday, meaning a ruling could come quickly.

NBC News also reports that Talwani found the Trump administration had violated her original injunction by moving forward with the Postal Service regulation despite her instruction not to, though she elected not to impose sanctions.

CNBC reports that 23 states, Washington D.C., and Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro filed a new lawsuit challenging the finalized rule, arguing it exceeds USPS statutory authority and violates the Voting Rights Act. The challengers can seek new injunctions at any time.

Sources

  1. cnbc.com › Federal judge lifts final block on Trump mail-in voting order, clearing way for midterm restrictions
  2. nbcnews.com › Judge allows Trump's mail-in ballots plan to proceed, at least for now
  3. thenation.com › The Supreme Court Is Helping Trump Rig the Midterms
  4. wpr.org › Supreme Court order on mail-in voting won't immediately affect Wisconsin ballots
  5. pbs.org › Supreme Court Decision on Mail-In Ballots Stirs Confusion. Here's What to Know
  6. coloradosun.com › What the US Supreme Court's ruling on Trump's order restricting mail voting means for Colorado

More on Politics