Judge Reblocks Trump's Mail Ballot Order

A federal judge temporarily halted USPS mail ballot rules days after the Supreme Court allowed them.

@sharedot

Judge Reblocks Trump's Mail Ballot Order

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Politics
  • Mail Voting
  • Supreme Court
  • 2026 Midterms
  • Election Administration

A federal judge temporarily halted USPS mail ballot rules days after the Supreme Court allowed them.

Judge Halts USPS Mail Ballot Plan

A federal judge in Boston has temporarily blocked the U.S. Postal Service from carrying out a plan issued under President Trump's executive order that could limit mail voting.

U.S. District Judge Indira Talwani granted a temporary restraining order for two weeks late Thursday night, halting the implementation just as the first mail ballots are due to be sent out for the rapidly approaching midterm elections.

The ruling stalls the directive for a second time, creating a whipsaw legal battle that has major ramifications for the November contests.

Days After a Supreme Court Win

The temporary restraining order comes just days after the Supreme Court's conservative majority lifted a previous injunction on Monday, allowing the Trump administration to move forward with elements of the executive order.

According to PBS, Trump called the Supreme Court's emergency order "a great ruling for the Republican Party" on Thursday. The Atlantic reports that the Court's Republican appointees acted via the shadow docket, lifting the injunction without ruling on the underlying legality of the executive order.

What the USPS Rule Requires

Under the Postal Service's final rule, issued late on a Friday night, states would be required to submit lists of their mail voters to USPS in order to use the service to transmit ballots.

According to CNN, USPS would only carry ballots in envelopes with specific bar codes unique to each voter to facilitate automated tracking, and the administration says the requirements are aimed at facilitating law enforcement investigations.

The Milwaukee Neighborhood News Service reports that the Postal Service stated it would decline to deliver mail-in ballots in states that do not provide the required voter list.

The rule also creates new ballot design standards and tracking requirements that states say are impossible to meet before November.

Stakes for the November Midterms

According to ABC News, nearly one-third of Americans vote by mail, and election officials contend there is not enough time to revise their systems to comply with the new Postal Service directives.

The timing is especially tight: PBS reports that Trump was asked about what the Supreme Court ruling means for states like North Carolina, where mail-in ballots are due to be sent out next week.

According to Shasta Scout, more than 89% of California voters used mail-in ballots in the latest June primary, underscoring how broadly the rule could affect voters if implemented.

The Judge's Legal Reasoning

Talwani wrote that the challengers are likely to win on their claims that the rule is unconstitutional and that USPS lacks authority to issue it in the first place.

NBC News reports that Talwani found the president cannot insert the federal government into elections without express authorization from Congress, and that the administration offered no evidence of fraudulent absentee or mail-in voting.

She wrote that the government's interest in correcting an unsubstantiated problem through likely unconstitutional means is dwarfed by the overwhelming risk of pervasive disenfranchisement.

States, she concluded, have neither time nor funds to redesign ballots, seek approval, update systems, train officials, and upload data before the midterms.

What Comes Next

A hearing is set for September 3 on whether to issue a preliminary injunction, which would be a longer-lasting block on the plan. According to ABC News, the case could soon be appealed back to the Supreme Court, days after the justices handed down their procedural decision.

NBC News reports that while the Postal Service regulation is now blocked, a provision of the executive order requiring the Department of Homeland Security to compile lists of eligible voters and send them to states remains in effect.

According to Shasta Scout, California has filed a new lawsuit in federal court in Massachusetts, with Attorney General Rob Bonta calling the Postal Service rules a clear violation of the Constitution's designation of states as the primary authority over elections.

Sources

  1. cnn.com › Judge pauses US Postal Service plan to implement Trump's new mail voting restrictions
  2. abcnews.com › Judge again blocks Trump mail ballot executive order in ruling that's likely to be swiftly appealed
  3. pbs.org › WATCH: Trump calls Supreme Court ruling on mail ballots 'great' for Republican Party
  4. theatlantic.com › The Supreme Court Isn't Interested in Facts
  5. milwaukeenns.org › What to know about US Supreme Court ruling on Trump's mail ballot restrictions
  6. shastascout.org › California sues to block Trump's mail-in voting rules just days after loss at Supreme Court
  7. nbcnews.com › Judge blocks Trump's Postal Service regulation on mail-in ballots

More on Politics