Defense Rests With No Witnesses in Faith Hedgepeth Murder Trial
By @sharedot · · 6 pages
- True Crime
- Faith Hedgepeth
- North Carolina
- Murder Trial
Miguel Salguero-Olivares declined to testify as his attorneys rested without calling any witnesses, sending the 2012 UNC murder case straight to closing arguments.
A surprise rest after nine days of prosecution evidence
In a move jurors did not expect, defense attorney James Rainsford told Judge Keith Gregory on Wednesday that the defense would present no evidence and call no witnesses in the trial of Miguel Salguero-Olivares, who has pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder, rape and burglary in the 2012 killing of UNC-Chapel Hill sophomore Faith Hedgepeth.
Salguero-Olivares told the judge directly, "I am not going to testify." Closing arguments were set for Thursday at 9:30 a.m.
The fight over who gets the last word
The rest triggered an unusual legal dispute over closing-argument order. Under North Carolina practice, a defense that puts on no evidence earns the right to argue last — the final word before the jury deliberates.
Judge Gregory said he remembered warning Rainsford on Monday that introducing evidence waived that right, which Rainsford disputed, arguing such a move would violate his client's constitutional rights.
After research, Gregory ruled that because the exhibit the defense offered was introduced out of the jury's presence, the defense keeps the right to the last argument.
According to WRAL, the judge said barring it could risk a conviction being overturned by the state appeals court, a risk he was unwilling to take, and prosecutors did not object.
The evidence the jury will weigh
Prosecutors rested their case Monday after SBI agent Justin Heinrich finished testifying. The News & Observer reports Heinrich corrected his own earlier testimony, acknowledging that a handwriting sample he had attributed to Salguero-Olivares was actually a widely circulated internet meme.
The state's case centers on DNA evidence it says links Salguero-Olivares to Hedgepeth's body, a glass rum bottle, boxer shorts and a white paper bag bearing a handwritten message.
The defense has questioned what that DNA and fingerprint evidence establishes about when he might have been in the apartment, and has challenged the investigation itself, citing a missing sample from a suspected bloodstain near the bathroom doorframe and items that went untested.
A fourteen-year-old case heads to the jury
Hedgepeth, a 19-year-old UNC sophomore, was found beaten to death in her off-campus apartment near the Durham–Chapel Hill border on Sept. 7, 2012.
Her murder went unsolved for nine years until Sept. 16, 2021, when Chapel Hill police arrested Salguero-Olivares after thousands of interviews and hundreds of DNA tests based on forensic evidence from the apartment.
The trial, which began Sept. 28, 2026, now moves to jury instructions and closing arguments, with the jury set to consider first- and second-degree murder, first-degree rape, first-degree sexual offense and first-degree burglary charges.
Judge Gregory and attorneys spent Wednesday afternoon finalizing the instructions jurors will receive before deliberations.