Judge Blocks Trump's New Birthright Citizenship Order

A federal judge in Maryland issued a preliminary injunction against Trump's August executive order targeting birthright citizenship, calling it almost certainly unconstitutional.

@sharedot

Judge Blocks Trump's New Birthright Citizenship Order

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Politics
  • Birthright Citizenship
  • Trump
  • Courts
  • Immigration

A federal judge in Maryland issued a preliminary injunction against Trump's August executive order targeting birthright citizenship, calling it almost certainly unconstitutional.

What happened

US District Judge Deborah Boardman of Maryland issued a preliminary injunction on Wednesday blocking enforcement of President Trump's August 6 executive order, which sought to deny citizenship to children of foreign nationals in certain groups, including those accused of engaging in a commercial transaction to obtain citizenship or classified as an "alien enemy."

Boardman wrote in a 35-page opinion that "The Supreme Court has spoken: Children in the certified class are 'citizens at birth.'"

The challenge was brought by immigrant rights advocates and families, including groups like the Asylum Seeker Advocacy Project, who had previously won an injunction from Boardman against Trump's initial birthright citizenship order.

Why it is surprising

This is the second time the administration's bid to restrict birthright citizenship has been struck down, even after the Supreme Court itself rejected the first attempt.

In June, the high court ruled 6-3 in Barbara v Trump that birthright citizenship is protected under the Fourteenth Amendment, with Chief Justice John Roberts writing that "Citizenship then and now, was the right to have rights."

Rather than accepting that defeat, Trump signed two new executive orders on August 6 probing new categories of exclusion — an unusual strategy that Boardman called "unprecedented" before ruling against it.

According to Euronews, rights groups like We Are CASA celebrated, with Legal Director Shana Khader saying the administration has now "lost before this court, lost before the Supreme Court, and lost again today."

The evidence in the ruling

Boardman's reasoning rested squarely on the June Supreme Court precedent.

She wrote that the August order "is almost certainly unconstitutional as applied to the certified class for the simple reason that the Supreme Court in Barbara already decided that the children in the class are citizens at birth."

According to NOTUS, the judge found the plaintiffs "have a strong likelihood of success" in their claim and wrote that "Barbara is the law of the land. The President must follow it."

She also rejected the Justice Department's argument that the lawsuit was premature, saying federal agencies would rely on enforcement guidance that had not yet been issued.

Per Euronews, she countered that "No matter what the guidance says, the 2026 Executive Order commands agencies to deny citizenship documents to several broad categories of children."

What the August orders targeted

The new executive orders, signed a month after the Supreme Court defeat, took aim at what Trump has called "birth tourism" — the practice of intentionally giving birth on foreign soil for citizenship reasons.

According to UPI, one August order expanded the list of non-citizens whose children would not automatically be granted citizenship, including children of a parent deemed "an alien enemy" or "a foreign government employee," while the other targeted the birth tourism ban.

The Justice Department argued the orders were compliant with the Barbara ruling and that agencies would use "appropriate measures" in enforcement, per NOTUS. UPI reports the practice targeted is already illegal under existing rules.

The stakes

The ruling is a major blow to Trump's wider immigration agenda, which Euronews reports includes expelling millions of undocumented migrants and removing deportation protections from nationals of more than a dozen countries. Activists say the stakes go beyond one order.

"The White House must recognise it will not succeed in stripping children of their right to citizenship, evading binding court decisions or placing the president's anti-immigrant agenda above the Constitution," Khader said, according to Euronews.

What comes next

The fight over birthright citizenship is now on a path to return to the Supreme Court.

According to The Japan Times, the US Justice Department next could ask a federal appeals court to lift the district judge's order and allow officials to move ahead with implementing the president's plan while the legal fights continue.

Trump, responding to the earlier June loss, called the ruling "too bad for our Country" and called on Congress to pass legislation against birthright citizenship, per UPI.

Sources

  1. aljazeera.com › US judge blocks Trump's latest effort to limit birthright citizenship
  2. notus.org › Federal Judge Blocks Trump's Latest Effort to Restrict Birthright Citizenship
  3. upi.com › Judge blocks Trump's latest try at limiting birthright citizenship
  4. euronews.com › Judge blocks new Trump bid against birthright citizenship
  5. japantimes.co.jp › Court halts Trump's new birthright citizenship curbs

More on Politics